Where does Floyd Mayweather Jr. rank on your ATG list

[Rabbit ♠]

I hear alot of people say he's not an ATG. I say he is. I think we just need to rank him somewhere. I think when some people say ATG they mean top 5 or 10. This poll will be based on top 100. So where do you rank Floyd? This is all opinion based and just wanted to see what the general consensus is on NSB. Poll coming.

[SugarRayRob]

hes somewhere in the top 1000

[Makavelli Jr.]

Your not going to get good results, based on this delusional forum.

I say between 21-30.. More towards 30.

[S.G.]

31-40 is fair IMO

[Rabbit ♠]

Your not going to get good results, based on this delusional forum.

I say between 21-30.. More towards 30.

31-40 is fair IMO

That's about where I have him. Mid to high 30's.. so 31-40 for me

[Rabbit ♠]

bump.................

[DiLLiNGER]

sugar ray robinson,muhammad ali,mike tyson,floyd mayweather.

[LilFloyd]

#786 just above matthew hatton

[jkaisen41]

I hear alot of people say he's not an ATG. I say he is. I think we just need to rank him somewhere. I think when some people say ATG they mean top 5 or 10. This poll will be based on top 100. So where do you rank Floyd? This is all opinion based and just wanted to see what the general consensus is on NSB. Poll coming.

Can't we wait til his career is over... I think legacy puts itself together from 3 parts
1. challenges
2. titles
3. name value

1. challenges are guys who are in their prime and legimate challengers or champions (his reigns at 130, 135 and even 147 had them) and fought about 15 champions or former champions until now
2. he has won 6 titles in 5 different divisions
3. name value until now is a bit lacking (of course he fouught guys like Corrales but they not in the same class as a Morales, Barrera, Mosley etc.) if he still adds to his name value (with Mosley and Pacquiao) he is easy Top30 probably even Top20

I will say this too... I've never seen a fighter who was a defensive mindset and still was so good at offense (I'm speaking generally for the weight classes under 147... at 147 he became more of an one shot artist)

[Rabbit ♠]

Can't we wait til his career is over... I think legacy puts itself together from 3 parts
1. challenges
2. titles
3. name value

1. challenges are guys who are in their prime and legimate challengers or champions (his reigns at 130, 135 and even 147 had them) and fought about 15 champions or former champions until now
2. he has won 6 titles in 5 different divisions
3. name value until now is a bit lacking (of course he fouught guys like Corrales but they not in the same class as a Morales, Barrera, Mosley etc.) if he still adds to his name value (with Mosley and Pacquiao) he is easy Top30 probably even Top20

I will say this too... I've never seen a fighter who was a defensive mindset and still was so good at offense (I'm speaking generally for the weight classes under 147... at 147 he became more of an one shot artist)

I hear you. I just want to know what people think where he stands right now. There's a few active boxers who are ATG. Roy, Bhop, Mosley, Mayweather, Pacquiao....