A question for Americans???

[MARKBNLV]

Hatton by far,Calzaghe is one of the most overrated fighters ever.

[daggum]

hatton could have been as good as calzaghe had he defended his belt in manchester for 10 years against bums then fought 40 year old floyd and manny. great career!

[AKATheMack]

Theres only one Ricky Hatton. I just feel Hatton pushed himself harder than Joe did. Fighting Tszyu, Manny and Floyd proved to me he wasn't afraid to lose.

[MidnightSpecial]

Hatton will go out on his shield. Its hard not to like a guy who is like that. He may not be full of skills but he makes up for it in heart.

Calzaghe slaps.

[sweetpea87]

I am a fan of both but I would say Calzaghe.

[DiegoFuego]

Anyone with a hint of talent can do what Calzaghe did, and I do mean ANYONE. Anybody could stay in his country and defend his title 20 times against guys who had no chance. The only respect I had for Joe was his win over Kessler, which Ward just made look pretty weak in November by doing a better job on Mikkel.

[Mr. Philadel]

this is easy......Hatton hands down!!!

[COYS]

hatton could have been as good as calzaghe had he defended his belt in manchester for 10 years against bums then fought 40 year old floyd and manny. great career!

believe me, that would have happened had he stayed with Frank Warren.

[Allucard]

i enjoy his fights...

he dominated, i dont ask for much more than that

Unless it's Floyd Mayweather. Then you'll also ask for: Knockouts, getting hit in the face as well and him fighting much bigger opponents for a 2 hour credit and back to hating after that.

Actually it's Ricky. He fought 2 p4p #1 prime champions whereas calzghe NEVER fought an A class fighter. Ever.