If Maywather vs Pacquiao was at 140, who wins?

[Method Checker]

They (arguably) both put on their most dominating performances at that weight. Who would win if the fight happened at 140, instead of 147?

EDIT: I don't mean if Mayweather and Pacquiao cut down to 140, right now. I mean if the 140 lb, 2005 version of Mayweather fought the 140 lb, 2009 version of Pacquiao.

[tanibanana]

from 130 to 147 Pac wins.. IMO

[Wupadupa]

pac would be celebrating win or lose, cuz floyd would have to pay him 30 million dollars in overweight penalties.

[[ DUBBZZ ]]

They (arguably) both put on their most dominating performances at that weight. Who would win if the fight happened at 140, instead of 147?

Right now? Pac. I say that because I feel that Pac would have an easier time making that weight than Floyd. If it was at 140 3-4 yrs ago, Floyd would take it.

[Method Checker]

I'm talking about the 140 version of Mayweather from 2005 against the 140 version of Pacquiao from 2009.

[DIB42]

We don't even know who wins at 147?

[dans]

Floyd wins

[Junito-Rulez]

Floyd was a beast when he just came from 135, so i'd pick Floyd. At 147, i really don't know. I'd probably pick Floyd but it's a 55% 45%; Pacquiao impressed me big time against Cotto.

[Weebler I]

Pacquiao wins at 140 imo, I have Floyd winning at 147.

[FLY TY]

at a weight floyd hasn't made in how long????

dumb thread.....

that's like saying a prime mike tyson versus chris byrd at 198....


how about keeping it real, at 147, which they were SCHEDULED TO FIGHT....

who wins?


140.....