Floyd Mayweather Jr Is And All Time great: I know It And You Know It

[Makavelli Jr.]

Listen you have your opinion and I have mine. Manny beat three fighters that Floyd also beat.(marquez,delahoya,hatton) You add barrera,cotto, and morrales for pacquiao, and you add corrales,castillio,judah,G.hernandez,gatti,baldomi r(who was ud champ) for Mayweather. Whats the difference?

You know what. Thats a helluva argument..

Mayweathers resume is just as good if not better then Pacs.

I just think Pac has the nod from accomplishments, and the fashion he complteted those accomplishments. If Marquez didn't get robbed, then it may be different.

[fdotorres]

You have never seen the fighters that they have beat. Look stop reading bio's. Get some tape and watch the fighters you speak of. I'm not saying they are not great, I' m saying how do you rank them over fighters you have seen in the ring. Just because some book ranks them top this or top that don't mean **** to me. I go by what I know and what I have seen.

exactly, you're a sad excuse of a boxing fan

[jrosales13]

You have never seen the fighters that they have beat. Look stop reading bio's. Get some tape and watch the fighters you speak of. I'm not saying they are not great, I' m saying how do you rank them over fighters you have seen in the ring. Just because some book ranks them top this or top that don't mean **** to me. I go by what I know and what I have seen.

Ok so you beat 10-15 HOF'ers and you only lose 20 fights out of 300 fights. But, there is no tape of you so you should not be ranked ahead of Floyd? Or Pac? Or Whitaker?

If you go from Lightweight-heavyweight and be a top level fighter in each division. But, there is no tape of you should not be ranked ahead of certain fighters?

Where is your top 25 list at? I am very curious to see it....

[dsyef]

Only in his mind. He didn't fight anyone he knew would beat him. Pacquiao, Margarito, Cotto, Mosley, Clottey, Berto. He just waits for them to beat the hell out of eachother.
His record is all he has and if he fought these fighter before they killed eachother he would be too hurt to beat anyone. He could've been like Whitaker, but with the loses good boxer, but never the best. Just the fighter who ran from the rest.

[bravocharly]

Please dont stoop to the low of *******s.

Id say Mayweather is a Top30-40 ATG, but no higher as of yet.

Is Top30-40 top at all ? May is only good in fighting who he has clear advantage of.He even cheats in weights (with JMM). If he is that great, he should just fight without so many running preconditions.

[fdotorres]

You know what. Thats a helluva argument..

Mayweathers resume is just as good if not better then Pacs.

I just think Pac has the nod from accomplishments, and the fashion he complteted those accomplishments. If Marquez didn't get robbed, then it may be different.

robbed of what? if anything, the one who got robbed was pacquiao, thanks to a judge's mistake

btw, castillo/floyd I is more of a robbery than any of pac's fights, don't try to forget that

[iskucha03]

this boxingfan is smoking something hahaha

[-EX-]

Some of the people in this thread probably didn't see Floyd pre-147...

[alexpz]

You *******s are not who I am talking to. It's the hardcore boxing people on this site. *******s think Manny is the greatest of all time lol. Detox first then we can talk.

ThePunchingBag a ***** just called you a ******* now.

Are you a ******* already? LMAO.

[deemortiz]

TRouble is ,he turned into a chicken, no... a duck, ah ..chicken ...oh hick. he's a chickenduck...