Floyd vs. Manny @ 130...who takes it?

[V.WEBB]

Floyd had a heck of a run at 130

defeating, G. Hernandez, Manfredy, Chico (Rip), Carlos Hernandez, Jesus Chavez



Manny had a heck of a run at 130 as well

defeating, Morales, Larios, Solis, Barerra, JMM



note: I didn't list all of their wins at 130

who do you see winning this fight in retrospect at 130?

no flaming...real discussion

[713832281]

pbf too nasty @ 130. as good as pac is, pbf just too good for him @ jlw.

[Dunkeroo23]

floyd was one of the greatest super featherweights of all time. at 130 manny got outboxed by morales and arguably lost to JMM. is this even a contest?

[Doctor_Tenma]

At 130, Pacquiao gets an ass whoppin.

[Rocker]

Mayweather would've won by decision.

[bdevils]

Floyd would prove to be too much for Manny @ 130 IMO. He had some pop, actually tried to put people away and just overwhelmed his opponents with his incredible speed and combinations

[-Swizzy-]

considering floyd was faster and more active at 130 than at 147 and pac looks like he is better at 140 than at 130, I would say Floyd by wide UD.

[CantBeTouched]

if a washed up morales and old JMM could beat up pac at 130, i can't imagine the ass whoopin floyd would have put on him

[oaba09]

if a washed up morales and old JMM could beat up pac at 130, i can't imagine the ass whoopin floyd would have put on him

Get your facts straight...only morales won over pacquiao......1st fight w/ JMM was a draw(supposedly a win for pacquiao but unfortunately, a judge forgot how to properly score the 1st round)....the 2nd fight was close but was won by manny because of that KD(I had him winning by 1 pt)....

On topic.......hard to predict...IMO 50/50

[boxaholic]

Get your facts straight...only morales won over pacquiao......1st fight w/ JMM was a draw(supposedly a win for pacquiao but unfortunately, a judge forgot how to properly score the 1st round)....the 2nd fight was close but was won by manny because of that KD(I had him winning by 1 pt)....

On topic.......hard to predict...IMO 50/50

I agree with everything except your prediction. Floyd was the greatest at 130 and should have stayed at 130 or 135. At 147 he is picking and chosing his opponents at 130 or 135 He would easily beat any and everybody. I would have loved to see Morales vs Floyd at 130 and Floyd vs Shane at 135 and now I'm wishful Floyd vs Pac at 147 will happen.