(POLL) Sergio Martinez vs Floyd Mayweather At 154lb Who Would Win?

[cotto16]

Lets say the Mayweather who fought Oscar vs the current 154lb Champion Sergio Martinez at 154lb.

Who Wins And How?

[Eaner0919]

Martinez. He is fairly big and fast so he could probably keep up with Floyd in the speed aspect and outmuscle him to boot. At some point size does become a factor and I think with this fighter and at this weight Floyd would hit the ceiling of what he can do

not to **** on Floyd I think most here know I am a fan but a truthful one. I also think Maravilla beats Manny too

[cotto16]

Martinez. He is fairly big and fast so he could probably keep up with Floyd in the speed aspect and outmuscle him to boot. At some point size does become a factor and I think with this fighter and at this weight Floyd would hit the ceiling of what he can do

not to **** on Floyd I think most here know I am a fan but a truthful one. I also think Maravilla beats Manny too

Interesting.............

[Jim Jeffries]

Martinez isn't an old, inactive DLH. Floyd would never fight him.

[Doctor_Tenma]

I give Mayweather a really good chance but I'm leaning towards Martinez. Martinez does get hit, lets remember that.

[Doctor_Tenma]

Martinez isn't an old, inactive DLH. Floyd would never fight him.

Since you're repetitive with that. Mayweather won't face anyone who doesn't bring $$.

[2501]

Martinez is just a bigger, more agressive less skilled Mayweather. Dont get it twisted though, I'm not saying he is on the same level as Floyd, but his size and speed and soufpaw style at 154 would be too much for Floyd. Those are the main attributes that would decide this fight. Close decision for Martinez.

Slick fighters have problems with slick fighters. That would go for both Martinez and Floyd.

[Easy-E]

Martinez isn't an old, inactive DLH. Floyd would never fight him.

Its crazy how that was pratically a pick 'em fight...until Floyd won, of course.
Then DLH was inactive, old, should have won, it was too close, Floyd showed he is not that good, etc etc.

[2501]

Its crazy how that was pratically a pick 'em fight...until Floyd won, of course.
Then DLH was inactive, old, should have won, it was too close, Floyd showed he is not that good, etc etc.

Pick em for Floyd fans, the majority of the boxing community, fairly simple fight for Floyd.

[Jim Jeffries]

Since you're repetitive with that. Mayweather won't face anyone who doesn't bring $$.

There was no guarantee that Marquez was going to bring in the kind of cash that he did.

But seriously, do you really think Floyd would ever fight a 54 pounder like Williams or Martinez, especially with his hesitance to fight even a top 47 pounder for the past several years?