if floyd beats manny where does that place him legacy wise as an atg..seriously

**NYU Alum** · 12-12-2009, 05:07 PM

Originally posted by larry x

with a win over manny where will you rank him atg wise..please no trolling

Well, since Manny is a top 5 ATG, and since Floyd's and Pac's opposition have been pretty much the same as of late....

**mike ruler** · 12-12-2009, 05:10 PM

Idk where Floyd falls on an ATG list. But, I'd like to say that I'm a Floyd fan, and by no means a hater, but I just wish that he would fight some real WW's. I firmly believe that he can beat them all, and I would give him the advantage against all of them. But in the end, if he doesn't fight some real WW's after the Pac fight, than that might ultimately do him in on an ATG list. But, he does have more than enough skill to be top 10 all time imo...

**FIGHTING_FLIP** · 12-12-2009, 05:12 PM

idk. im a floyd fan but i feel like if pacquaio wins it does more for pacquioas legacy..but if floyd beats pacquiao, it doesnt do much for maywetaher legacy..weird

**larry x** · 12-12-2009, 05:13 PM

Originally posted by mike ruler

Idk where Floyd falls on an ATG list. But, I'd like to say that I'm a Floyd fan, and by no means a hater, but I just wish that he would fight some real WW's. I firmly believe that he can beat them all, and I would give him the advantage against all of them. But in the end, if he doesn't fight some real WW's after the Pac fight, than that might ultimately do him in on an ATG list. But, he does have more than enough skill to be top 10 all time imo...

isnt manny a "real"ww?? didnt he just beat the **** out of cotto a "real" ww??? come on with that other than shane who's at ww that floyd has to fight????

**larry x** · 12-12-2009, 05:15 PM

Originally posted by NYU Alum

Well, since Manny is a top 5 ATG, and since Floyd's and Pac's opposition have been pretty much the same as of late....

lmfao./.manny is not a top 5 atg..who told you this???top 25 maybe...but top 5????lol

**phallus** · 12-12-2009, 05:15 PM

floid's expected to beat manny, it won't do much for his legacy...it'd be better legacy wise for him to beat sugar shane

**-MAKAVELLI-** · 12-12-2009, 05:16 PM

Originally posted by phallus

floid's expected to beat manny, it won't do much for his legacy...it'd be better legacy wise for him to beat sugar shane

this................

**RodBarker** · 12-12-2009, 05:17 PM

Originally posted by FIGHTING_FLIP

idk. im a floyd fan but i feel like if pacquaio wins it does more for pacquioas legacy..but if floyd beats pacquiao, it doesnt do much for maywetaher legacy..weird

Weird alright , Pac is a full fledged welter after the Cotto fight , he is current P4P No 1 and is fighter of the decade ,,, its a great scalp on Floyds resume considering all the people that say Floyd is gunna get slaughtered , you cant have it both ways , its great for Pac but ordinary for Floyd thats a crock of **** if I ever heard one .

**larry x** · 12-12-2009, 05:17 PM

Originally posted by FIGHTING_FLIP

idk. im a floyd fan but i feel like if pacquaio wins it does more for pacquioas legacy..but if floyd beats pacquiao, it doesnt do much for maywetaher legacy..weird

so in your opinion floyds an atg and mannys not..cause what you said made no sense..in other words floyd gets no credit for beating anyone..but anyone who beats floyd is an instant legend

if floyd beats manny where does that place him legacy wise as an atg..seriously