Zab Judah, Carlos Quintana and Luis Collazo

[Bushbaby]

Collazo is the best out of the 3,period!!I believe they say his hand was badly damaged early in the fight with Mosley!!Not saying he would have won,but maybe not be beaten as badly!!

I don't know how Judah got to be linear at 147,but at least he was at 1 time!!His stamina sucks & he folds heavily under pressure!!

Quintana does hold the huge win over the Punisher,that was his greatest highpoint career wise!!He may have been better but he is somewhat like Cotto,them boys can't handle return fire!!But the difference between him & Cotto is Cotto sure can ****!!

[DLT]

Collazo is the best out of the 3,period!!I believe they say his hand was badly damaged early in the fight with Mosley!!Not saying he would have won,but maybe not be beaten as badly!!

I don't know how Judah got to be linear at 147,but at least he was at 1 time!!His stamina sucks & he folds heavily under pressure!!

Quintana does hold the huge win over the Punisher,that was his greatest highpoint career wise!!He may have been better but he is somewhat like Cotto,them boys can't handle return fire!!But the difference between him & Cotto is Cotto sure can ****!!

I think Zab may be getting a bad rap. Some things are definatly true but he also just physicaly isnt that big. He didnt have any problems at 140 and he was good at WW early because he was facing a soft puncher pure boxer in Spinks, who does have mad skill though. Then he fought a 165 pound Baldy while he himself was only 146. Then he lost to the best in Floyd. Then a prime Cotto who was huge at the time. And then a prime Clottey who was also huge. He just didnt belong there. I dont think he ran out of gas as people say. He never did that before the Baldy fight. He was never a 3 or 4 round fighter. I think Floyd just figured him out like everyone else does and I think the other guys were physicaly just too big & strong for him. His skills can get him by the first few rounds and then those guys size & pressure take over. If he's down at 140 then I dont think he looks like a 4 round fighter again but the questions are can he still make 140 comfortably and even if he can, has the fight been beat out of him by now?

[Cockfighter69]

1. Judah








































































































































































2. Collazo
3. Quitana

[rj_ct]

I always root for Zabdiel, but I hate when people say, "He's got so much skill, he just lacks mental focus." If you can't focus of a fight for a full 12 rounds, you are NOT a highly skilled fighter. He's got hand speed, but hand speed isn't the same thing as skill.

Collazo is the best fighter out of those 3 in my opinion.

[123tyson123]

1Quintana
2Collazo
3Judah

fan of all 3 of them, fantastic fighters.

[savorduhflavor]

Quintana is clearly the best of them. Don't see how it's that close.

[Mighty_Windir]

Not to disagree with anyone but I say Collazo whoops them.

1) Collazo
2) Quintana
3) Judah

[[ILLMatic]]

Quintana
Collazo
Judah


Judah is more talented than Quintana and Collazo ut only for 3 or 4 rounds!!

Co Sign!!!!!

[boxasmash]

Poll added because of conflicting views.

[ELHURACAN58]

Quintana
Collazo
Judah

Quintana is the more powerful of the three, and because neither Collazo nor Judah have good defense, Quinatna knocks both of them out.