Who is Greater De La Hoya or Calzaghe?

[The_Demon]

De la hoya
like Soy said in his post,people seem too forget how good a young oscar was

[S H O B O X]

dlh by a wide margin

[tornillo57]

As in who ranks higher on the ATG list? I say De La Hoya because the level of fighters he fought and beat are superior than Calzaghes....
Vote and Discuss

DLH's legacy is much greater, but prime Calslappy vs prime chicken DLH, Calslappy wins hands down.

[Dynamite Kid]

Oscar is greater, people forget how good Oscar was in his younger days. Calzaghe never faced the quality of opponents Oscar did. As for Calzaghe being an ATG, I don't think so. I don't even think Oscar is an ATG. Maybe if he didn't get robbed in the rematch against Shane and against Tito.

This, well more so the bolded part.

[chinoy]

ODLH is greater.....i have seen all of ODLH fights when he was younger and boy was he great....

if you compare Joe's achievements to ODLH, it will pale in comparison for the fact that Joe has been beating unknown's.....his win over BHOP is probably his greatest achievement but that is all there is and it could have gone both ways....

[gibo]

Joe beat everyone he was suppose to beat. hoja lost to everyone he was suppose to beat!!! Who's better?

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

They are about the same.


Oscar Lack of accomplishments is overshadow by the great resume he have!

And Calzaghes lack of resume is overruled by his great accompsihments. It doesnt get any etter than having the 4 major belts in your division, being the lineal/Ring Champion plus 21 succesfull title defenses!!