Comments Thread For: CompuBox Post Analysis: Paul Williams vs Sergio Martinez

[BIGPOPPAPUMP]

When it was announced that Sergio Martinez would replace Kelly Pavlik as Paul Williams’ opposition, the boxing cognoscenti envisioned a skilled but somewhat subdued night at the fights. [Click Here To Read More]

[Fistic]

IMO Martinez won that fight. 119-110 is just ridiculous and I'm glad that Max Kellerman called the judge out at the end--their needs to be more accountability in these matters.

[mathed]

IMO Martinez won that fight. 119-110 is just ridiculous and I'm glad that Max Kellerman called the judge out at the end--their needs to be more accountability in these matters.

That judge is a crook, fight should have been a draw IMO

And to the people making a big del about Williams landing more and throwing more:

Williams threw 611 more punches than Martinez but only landed 46 more punches than he did. This extra effort by Williams amounted to a whopping connect percentage of 7.5%

Williams threw 185 more power punches than Martinez and landed 23 more than Martinez. This equates to a connect percentage of 12.4%.

I know that being more active is usually a good thing but it seems like there was a lot of inefficient going on for Williams while Martinez was accurate and effective with punches. Either way you look at it, 119-110 is absurd.

[El Castigador]

115-113 Williams.

[WESS]

Rematch

Draw..........

[LEFTYGUNZZ]

Draw..........

I seen it going for Martinez.... either 115-113 or 116-112....Even the 114-114 card was good but 119-110 come on gentlemen that is a disgrace to all judges even Ray Charles could have done a better job scoring that bout then that ridiculous score....Lefty

[YoUnG PW]

115-113...pw aggressiveness created the fight....what if paul wasnt the busier fighter?? the fight wouldve been boring ass ****...yea he was getting his head knocked back but it made no affect, he continued to come foward....martinez was shock 2.....

119-110 was bull****....and it happens in boxing so much that i dont know if it will ever go away....anyways besides that 119-110 that fight was classic and deserves a rematch...i would pay to watch the rematch.....

[Bushbaby]

I saw the fight again last night & rescored it,I saw the fight mostly like Lederman did,except for rounds 8 & 11!!I thought the Punisher jab was landing too freely in round 8 to give it to Martinez & I think Martinez answered everything the Punisher offered in round 11!!7-5 on rounds for the Punisher!!

[la pantera]

Not happy with that inept judge? let the commish hear about it..

For emails & calls regarding Pierre Benoist's scoring in Atlantic City, contact Aaron Davis, NJ ACB Commissioner @ (609) 292-0317, FAX him @ (609) 292-3756 or email him @ aaron.davis@lps.state.nj.us.

[THE REED]

115-114 Williams

Round 1: 10-9 Martinez

Round 12: 10-10 Even