Who are your top 15 P4P fighters?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • HaglerSteelChin
    Self-Exiled
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Nov 2009
    • 1737
    • 96
    • 98
    • 8,163

    #1

    Who are your top 15 P4P fighters?

    We are getting close to the end of the year and instead of taking Ring Magazine's ratings i think it would be interesting to rate your top 15 P4P.
    I am sure some notable guys were left out like Pavlik but he didnt do much this year and beating a tomato can in a week or two dosent say much.

    15-IVAN CALDERON
    14-TIMONTHY BRADLEY
    13-LUCIAN BUTE
    12-DAVID HAYE
    11-ARTHUR ABRAHAM
    10-JUAN MANUEL LOPEZ
    9-NONITO DONAIRE
    8-PAUL WILLIAMS
    7-PONSAKLEK WONJONGKAM
    6-SHANE MOSLEY
    5-VITALI KLITSCHKO
    4-CHAD DAWSON
    3-BERNARD HOPKINS
    2-FLOYD MAYWEATHER JR
    1-MANNY PACQUIAO
  • dde91
    Undisputed Champion
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Oct 2008
    • 2686
    • 86
    • 20
    • 9,217

    #2
    Originally posted by HaglerSteelChin
    We are getting close to the end of the year and instead of taking Ring Magazine's ratings i think it would be interesting to rate your top 15 P4P.
    I am sure some notable guys were left out like Pavlik but he didnt do much this year and beating a tomato can in a week or two dosent say much.

    15-IVAN CALDERON
    14-TIMONTHY BRADLEY
    13-LUCIAN BUTE
    12-DAVID HAYE
    11-ARTHUR ABRAHAM
    10-JUAN MANUEL LOPEZ
    9-NONITO DONAIRE
    8-PAUL WILLIAMS
    7-PONSAKLEK WONJONGKAM
    6-SHANE MOSLEY
    5-VITALI KLITSCHKO
    4-CHAD DAWSON
    3-BERNARD HOPKINS
    2-FLOYD MAYWEATHER JR
    1-MANNY PACQUIAO
    that is a pretty legit list. mine is

    1.Pacquiao
    2.Bernard Hopkins
    3.Juan Manuel Marquez
    4.Shane Mosley
    5.Floyd Mayweather Jr.
    6.Paul Williams
    7.Chad Dawson
    8.Arthur Abraham
    9.Miguel Cotto
    10.Donaire
    11.Pascal
    12.Bradley
    13.KLIT Bros next 2 slots
    14.
    15.David Haye

    THE HEAVYWEIGHTS could get up more when they fight eachother, but i think i should put David Haye infront of the Klits because he was CW champion. But the Klits been Dominating the HW's for the past several years, but these years of heavyweights haven't been that good. But who ever beats who will probably go up in my list.

    Comment

    • MidnightSpecial
      Banned
      Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
      • Oct 2009
      • 11412
      • 596
      • 269
      • 23,646

      #3
      the way i see a P4P list is that the fighter could willingly and successfully navigate another weight class.

      The Klit brothers by no way in hell can fight in another weight class.

      Comment

      • illmatickid
        Undisputed Champion
        Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
        • Jun 2009
        • 1345
        • 65
        • 22
        • 7,578

        #4
        i dont think theres 15 boxers that deserve to be on a pound for pound
        only about 7-8 boxers at least in my eyes
        thats just me tho

        Comment

        • HaglerSteelChin
          Self-Exiled
          Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
          • Nov 2009
          • 1737
          • 96
          • 98
          • 8,163

          #5
          Originally posted by dde91
          that is a pretty legit list. mine is

          1.Pacquiao
          2.Bernard Hopkins
          3.Juan Manuel Marquez
          4.Shane Mosley
          5.Floyd Mayweather Jr.
          6.Paul Williams
          7.Chad Dawson
          8.Arthur Abraham
          9.Miguel Cotto
          10.Donaire
          11.Pascal
          12.Bradley
          13.KLIT Bros next 2 slots
          14.
          15.David Haye

          THE HEAVYWEIGHTS could get up more when they fight eachother, but i think i should put David Haye infront of the Klits because he was CW champion. But the Klits been Dominating the HW's for the past several years, but these years of heavyweights haven't been that good. But who ever beats who will probably go up in my list.
          yes i put haye there not only for his win against Valuev but also due to his CW title. But he deserves special honor for saving us from seeing that 7 feet ugly thing again, kidding.

          Comment

          • LilGizmo562
            Banned
            Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
            • Oct 2008
            • 1675
            • 43
            • 149
            • 1,957

            #6
            1.Manny Pacquiao
            2.Shane Mosley
            3.Juan Manuel Marquez
            4.Floyd Mayweather
            5.Chad Dawson
            6.Miguel Cotto
            7.Timothy Bradley
            8.Bernard Hopkins
            9.Paul Williams
            10.Nonito Donaire
            11.Arthur Abraham
            12.Caballero
            13.Juanma Lopez
            14.Hasawega (think thats how you spell it)
            15.Ivan Calderon
            Last edited by LilGizmo562; 12-06-2009, 07:12 PM.

            Comment

            • steeluv
              Interim Champion
              • Jul 2009
              • 969
              • 39
              • 76
              • 7,167

              #7
              15 - Y GAMBOA
              14 - ANDRE WARD
              13-PAUL WILLIAMS
              12-IVAN CALDERON
              11-LUCIAN BUTE
              10-DAVID HAYE
              9 - CHRIS JOHN
              8-ARTHUR ABRAHAM
              7-JUAN MANUEL LOPEZ
              6-PONSAKLEK WONJONGKAM
              5-VITALI KLITSCHKO
              4-BERNARD HOPKINS
              3-SHANE MOSLEY
              2-FLOYD MAYWEATHER JR
              1-MANNY PACQUIAO

              I have to take out Bradley he aint fought Khan or Hatton, im think its a toss up between him and hatton, not convinced he can beat Khan, im pretty confident after khan fights a couple of stronger opponents he will slaughter that guy if they meet he is way faster, and he has improved a million times since freddie roach, accuracy and defence wise

              I take out chad Dawson, u can't score no points with me if u go around beating and rematching old men move division if u got no one to fight! like real pound for pounders do, dont comeback with that crappy super middleweight title he won against who exactly? who did he fight in that division, i think its a straight nobody.

              Comment

              • Xcusemymood
                Undisputed Champion
                • Dec 2008
                • 1624
                • 67
                • 229
                • 7,760

                #8
                1. Manny Pacquiao
                2. Floyd Mayweather
                3. Chad Dawson
                4. Shane Mosley
                5. Bernard Hopkins
                6. Paul Williams
                7. Juan Manuel Marquez
                8. Ivan Calderon
                9. Sergio Martinez
                10. Andre Ward
                11. Arthur Abraham
                12. Juan Manuel Lopez
                13. Yuriorkis Gamboa
                14. Celestino Caballero
                15. Tim Bradley

                Ive never seen Hasegawa so its hard for me to put him on there.

                Although I think Mayweather may be a better boxer Pac has been taking care of biz impressively so hes number 1.

                Im sure Ill catch some heat having Dawson so high up but I have no doubt hed handle Hopkins(or anyone at LHW) at this stage.

                I think Pwill would beat Mosley because of styles but still rank Mosley as a better fighter all around. In fact I wanted to move Pwill down the list based on the fact hes so hittable, but still cant think of many guys who would actually beat him.

                Marquez is what he is although I think weve seen his best.

                Calderon is a good little fighter but hard to rank him any higher.

                Martinez cracks the top 10 based on the fact his last few even though hes had bad luck on decisions, wanted to put him closer to Pwill but his resume doesnt give him a spot over Marquez yet.

                Ward may be in here a little too soon but based on how he looked against Miranda and Kessler I am pretty sold on him being quality.

                Everything about Abraham tells me hes the man, but, he still doesnt have the best resume either, wins over Miranda and Taylor are impressive but both those guys had been stopped bad recently.

                Juanma, Gamboa, and Cab need to battle it out in the ring. Not sure whos where yet.....

                Tim Bradley. Not the most special at any one thing but his last 3 fights have showed us the guy can fight and he deserves a spot at the top for now.
                Last edited by Xcusemymood; 12-07-2009, 03:04 AM.

                Comment

                • nachorjj
                  Undisputed Champion
                  • Feb 2008
                  • 2014
                  • 35
                  • 80
                  • 8,284

                  #9
                  15-OMAR NARVAEZ
                  14-TIMONTHY BRADLEY
                  13-SERGIO MARTINEZ
                  12-ARTHUR ABRAHAM
                  11-LUCIAN BUTE
                  10-NONITO DONAIRE
                  9-PONSAKLEK WONJONGKAM
                  8-CHAD DAWSON
                  7-DAVID HAYE
                  6-VITALI KLITSCHKO
                  5-BERNARD HOPKINS
                  4-SHANE MOSLEY
                  3-JUAN MANUEL MARQUEZ
                  2-FLOYD MAYWEATHER JR
                  1-MANNY PACQUIAO
                  __________________
                  TOP 15 Favorite Fighters Of All Time

                  1-Roy Jones Jr.
                  2-Sugar Ray Leonard
                  3-Pernell Whitaker
                  4-Floyd Mayweather Jr
                  5-Manny Pacquiao
                  6-Muhammad Ali
                  7-Mike Tyson
                  8-Shane Mosley
                  9-Aaron Pryor
                  10-Oscar De La Hoya
                  11-James Toney
                  12-Joe Frazier
                  13-Roberto Duran
                  14-Marvin Hagler
                  15-Bernard Hopkins

                  Comment

                  Working...
                  TOP