Who really won PW vs SM?

[WarriorMan]

So far what this poll shows is there are alot of people that are maybe Cotto, Pac, Floyd fans hating on Williams. Because they're were not that many SM fans before this fight. Though I believe he earned some tonight. Not that many people really believe SM won. The 119 -110 was ridiculous.

[#4#king]

hard fight to score...i would have given martinez the slight nod...

the dude responsible for the 119-110 score should never be allowed to watch boxing again...what a moron...

[Pullcounter]

A draw or one round either way is ok, but 119-110 means martinez was robbed.

[WarriorMan]

Sergio Martinez clearly won the fight 115-113 on my card.

His punches were clean and effective, Williams was missing most of the time.

If it was that clear you would not have scored it with a one point difference. Because 1 round and its a draw. so nothing clear.

[Steak]

This was in no way a robbery. A very close, entertaining fight.

A Draw is actually a very legitimate and fair score.

That being said, I thought Martinez won. The only round I have second guesses on would be the 5th round, and with that it would be a draw.

Great stuff, I would LOVE to see a rematch at 154lbs, with a 154lb belt on the line.

I just thought Martinez was landing the harder shots in a lot of the rounds, and I think Martinez's work to the body is being very underappreciated. he landed solid body punches, while Williams...eh. most of his to the body were shoeshine.
Williams' left eye was pretty chopped up.
Martinez was absolutely exhausted at the end of the 12th, lol.

I was amazed that Lederman thought Williams won the 11th round. thought that was CLEARLY Martinez's round.
Was surprised that Kellerman thought Martinez won. He usually loves Williams. He did a good job tonight.

[oldgringo]

Martinez by the hair of his ****les.

[WarriorMan]

A draw or one round either way is ok, but 119-110 means martinez was robbed.

one judges score does not change what the whole fight and what the fighters did.

[Porter's Dad]

I had Martinez deserved it. On a round by round scoring basis, and just the way he fought overall in the fight. The rounds Paul won weren't as clear as Martinez's. Props to Williams, he played his part in by far the best fight of the year.

[#4#king]

So far what this poll shows is there are alot of people that are maybe Cotto, Pac, Floyd fans hating on Williams. Because they're were not that many SM fans before this fight. Though I believe he earned some tonight. Not that many people really believe SM won. The 119 -110 was ridiculous.

not really dude...im a huge p-will fan...i just watch fights with an open mind, because im not 12 years old and dont have crushes on grown men...

it was a close fight that was hard to score...simple...im pretty sure most people who watched that fight objectively -- like myself -- thought martinez did more to win it...

[-EX-]

Martinez dominating the poll...although some may be pissed cuz of that judge