Make it happen!! Hopkins vs. Toney at catch weight..

[photomane]

Who wins and how?

[Crazylegs77]

hmm not a bad idea

[Doctor_Tenma]

Toney is done, more done then Roy is.

[dde91]

Hopkins by UD. Toney is past it right now

[obaioghill]

Hopkins by UD. Toney is past it right now

Agreed -Toney is played out - this would still be an interesting fight. I think it would be good for both of them.

[MARKBNLV]

i made a post about this a week ago . but anyway i see toney losing a close decision

[dde91]

James Toney's reflexes and speed isn't there no more. Hopkins isn't PRIME hopkins, but he is still one of the top dogs in the game. It would probably look like Hopkins vs Winky IMO. a lot of Rough Tatics.

[Sicario]

why would they even make this fight?

[Heru]

I suggest you go see the Greer fight, then come back with a straight face to say this.

If Toney ever managed to get down to a 190 or 200 pound catchweight, he'd be like Byrd was losing all his punch resistance.

[DLT]

How do you guys know that Toney is done? We all know his age but he has also been really fat lately. Thats the bigger reason why I think he has looked like crap. IF he got back in shape, which he would have to do for a catchweight fight, then I think he will still look good