What about Mayweather/Judah II?

[bojangles1987]

If Mayweather absolutely has to fight a SECOND tuneup before fighting Pac or Mosley, it better be against a relevant welterweight. Zab Judah a second time is a damn joke.

[Bushbaby]

On a serious note,Collazo-floyd will be a hell of a matchup!!Collazo has the skills to hang around & make it interesting as he losses in a close fight,with all the support he gets for the 2 horrible decisions he has suffered!!

[S.G.]

On a serious note,Collazo-floyd will be a hell of a matchup!!Collazo has the skills to hang around & make it interesting as he losses in a close fight,with all the support he gets for the 2 horrible decisions he has suffered!!

Which kind of makes it something more than a tune-up and not what Floyd appears to be looking for.

[Rampage1978]

I'd prefer Pacquiao-Mayweather I. Nothing else. No tune ups, no delays, just get it done!

[larry x]

Well if you recall Judah gave him a lot of problems early. If not for the DQ we might have had a classic fight. The other guys you mentioned to not possess Judah's combination of hand speed, power, quickness, awkwardness and foot speed. Sure Judah doesn't train properly but his natural skill set is 10X better than the fighters you mentioned. Out of those names Collazo should be the only other one considered.

there was no DQ..and judah didnt do anything after the 4th or 5th round..........it was pretty one sided after that....floyd gets no credit for the first judah fight..why would he fight him again??

[Bushbaby]

Which kind of makes it something more than a tune-up and not what Floyd appears to be looking for.

But this fight would be credible,after the Marquez fiasco,floyd should fight a ranked welterweight,but it might be more than what floyd is looking for like u say,though!!

[aether]

No no, only one man left for Floyd to fight:

there's gonna be a 24/7 if this happens.

[Syf]

I know everyone wants Mayweather/Pacquiao as do I and I am sure we eventually get it. But if Pacquiao is going to focus on these elections in the PI and Mayweather wants a fight in between time why not Judah?

Southpaw, marketable, world class skill set, a lot of left over drama from the first meeting

I see this as the perfect fight for Mayweather. His haters can't flame him for fighting a Matthew Hatton type, he gets a slick power punching soutpaw to help prep for Pacquiao, he makes good money.

Zab would jump all over it because of how broke he is.

I think it is a good fit

People don't even give Floyd respect for his first Judah win..what makes you think a second win over Judah would mean anything?

[Rabbit ♠]

[DC Fight Fan]

there was no DQ..and judah didnt do anything after the 4th or 5th round..........it was pretty one sided after that....floyd gets no credit for the first judah fight..why would he fight him again??

My bad I didn't mean DQ I was just referring to the fouling and controversy. Dave Moretti scored the fight properly though giving Judah 4 out of the first 5 rounds. Earl Judah was on his game. Mayweather clearly won the fight but Judah showed more against Mayweather than any other fighter that Mayweather has fought between 40/47.