Which is The Better P4P Rankings? Yahoo Sports or Ring (Latest Update)

[MakeDamnSure]

Yahoo Sports:

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
3. Paul Williams
4. Shane Mosley
5. (tie) Bernard Hopkins
5. (tie) Juan Manuel Marquez
7. Chad Dawson
8. Arthur Abraham
9. Wladimir Klitschko
10. Miguel Cotto


Ring Magazine P4P Rankings

1. Manny Pacquiao

2. Floyd Mayweather Jr.

3. Shane Mosley

4. Bernard Hopkins

5. Juan Manuel Marquez

6. Nonito Donaire

7. Miguel Cotto

8. Celestino Caballero

9. Chad Dawson

10. Paul Williams

[P.WILL]

Yahoo Sports...........but shouldn't hopkins and mosley be off of the list for not fighting over an year??????

[DLT]

the rings is better

[Spray_resistant]

I like yahoo's imaginary scale down the best fighters in the world tourney champions list better and Ring's.

[Rizwan Khalil]

The Ring is better, though neither is perfect.

Roy Jones deserves a spot.

[ianntheman]

Yahoo Sports...........but shouldn't hopkins and mosley be off of the list for not fighting over an year??????

cause pwill is number 3.............. after martinez beat pwill he wont be in the list....

[Pullcounter]

the Ring is better. Pwill is too high on the list and AA and Wlad shouldn't be on the list

[P.WILL]

cause pwill is number 3.............. after martinez beat pwill he wont be in the list....

Martinez will recieve punishment dec.5

[Dambala]

The Ring, but I'd switch Donaire for Dawson, put Williams on Caballero's spot kicking him out and adding Wlad.

[Ekscape]

Paul Williams hasnt done enough to number #3 IMO... If he beats Martinez then Pavlik then yes he deserves that #3 spot