Who would win between a PRIME Roy Jones Jr and Joe Calzaghe?

[RockyB]

Roy Jones would whoop his ass

[Lead Cenobite]

You didn't read my whole post or you're just very ******. Either way, we're done here.

He's just a huge fanqueen. He doesn't even have the balls to admit he's horribly biased. Either that or he's missing major parts of his brain stem.

[shade darkar]

ha gutted. Lead Cenobite you are wasting your time seen as tho iv ignored you. now fcuk off back to your slums.

[Lead Cenobite]

ha gutted. Lead Cenobite you are wasting your time seen as tho iv ignored you. now fcuk off back to your slums.

******* with no argument use ignore. Glad you did though becuase your lack of intelligence is beginning to hurt my head.

[Calza appy]

Roy Jones Jr vs Joe Calzaghe, prime for prime. Who would win?

Imo Roy Jones Jr by KO. A totally shot and 40 year old RJJ knocked down and seriously hurt Calzaghe in the first round. A PRIME Roy Jones Jr would have ended it right there.

Im sorry but why does everyone think Joe was in his prime too, he was 36-37 odd years old!! If it was a prime Calzaghe at 27 or 28 it versus a prime RJJ it would be the same result.

[DiegoFuego]

Im sorry but why does everyone think Joe was in his prime too, he was 36-37 odd years old!! If it was a prime Calzaghe at 27 or 28 it versus a prime RJJ it would be the same result.

Calzaghe's prime was 2006-2008. How else can you explain him never fighting a decent opponent until then?

So are you admitting Calzaghe ducked opponents his entire career until the last 2 years?

[Lead Cenobite]

Im sorry but why does everyone think Joe was in his prime too, he was 36-37 odd years old!! If it was a prime Calzaghe at 27 or 28 it versus a prime RJJ it would be the same result.

I have posted this a few times now, and I wish Joe fans would get it already. It wasn't Roy's age. STOP COMPARING JOE with ROY and saying Joe was "old too". It's such a weak ****ing pathetic cop out ***** move that frankly it's embarrassing.

Roy was SHOT AND OLD and DONE in 2004. The end.

Joe's fans are insane.

[Lead Cenobite]

[QUOTE=Calza appy;6797992]Im sorry but why does everyone think Joe was in his prime too, he was 36-37 odd years old!! If it was a prime Calzaghe at 27 or 28 it versus a prime RJJ it would be the same result.[/QUOTE]

What the **** are you basing this on. YOu know what Joe Calzaghe DID at that prime age?

I'll tell you what:


FOUGHT-

2001-04-28 167¾ Mario Veit 167 30-0-0


2000-12-16 167¾ Richie Woodhall 167½ 26-2-0


2000-08-12 168 Omar Sheika 167 20-1-0


2000-01-29 167¾ David Starie 167½ 22-1-0
~

1999-06-05 167½ Rick Thornberry 167 23-2-0


1999-02-13 167 Robin Reid 167¾ 26-1-1


That's what did from around 27-28ish or so. WOW. Prime Roy would be toast I guess.

[DiegoFuego]

[QUOTE=Lead Cenobite;6798063]

Im sorry but why does everyone think Joe was in his prime too, he was 36-37 odd years old!! If it was a prime Calzaghe at 27 or 28 it versus a prime RJJ it would be the same result.[/QUOTE]

What the **** are you basing this on. YOu know what Joe Calzaghe DID at that prime age?

I'll tell you what:


FOUGHT-

2001-04-28 167¾ Mario Veit 167 30-0-0


2000-12-16 167¾ Richie Woodhall 167½ 26-2-0


2000-08-12 168 Omar Sheika 167 20-1-0


2000-01-29 167¾ David Starie 167½ 22-1-0
~

1999-06-05 167½ Rick Thornberry 167 23-2-0


1999-02-13 167 Robin Reid 167¾ 26-1-1


That's what did from around 27-28ish or so. WOW. Prime Roy would be toast I guess.

Exactly. Guys don't waste their primes fighting that list of deadly opponents. His prime was the last 3 years of his career. Otherwise, he would have fought ONE good fighter at some point along the way.

[knockoutQ]

Roy would hurt this guy

On top of Roy ot being close to what he used to be, lets not forget he got cut bad over the eye and Roy had never been cut before