Who would win between a PRIME Roy Jones Jr and Joe Calzaghe?

[Lead Cenobite]

lol, if calzaghe was a yank, they'd be all over him like a rash. but because he is european he aint ****. thats the way the yanks look at things. strange when you think that it was in england where the game started!

Again, sub-moronic post.

It ahs nothing to do with being a "yank" (seriously will you idiots ever learn that Yank doesn't even mean American?). If so why do American's root for Mexcian fighters or Puerto Rican fighters? Hmmm?

Strange. And Floyd Mayweather is American and has plenty of American haters. On this board most people hate him. Strange when you think about how ****** your theory is....

[shade darkar]

I know you are incredibly biased and a Joe fanqueen but try this:

It's not all about age. Roy was a few months from 40 btw since his bday is in January. It's about the fact that Roy was more SHOT and OLD than Joe. Roy had been brutally KOED twice YEARS before the Joe fight.

Stop comparing Joe's age to him and acting like Joe was old or shot. Joe's workrate indicates there was no decline in stamina due to age. In fact that ONLY difference between older Joe and young Joe was throwing fewer power shots and more flurries (although that could be chalked up to a slight increase in competition going from the Veit's of the world to the Kesslers of the world).

The comparison is ******ed....Roy was very shot. It was a terrible useless win for Joe. Anyone who thinks it was a good win for Joe needs to stop watching boxing and stick to eating lead paint. The only thing that sounds ****** is biased or young or new Joe fanboys thinking that fight meant anything.

wrong, im not even a calzaghe fan. try again. yeah, well the ts made it out that he was 40 and soooooo much older than calzaghe. if roy was so shot, which im not claiming he was or wasnt, then why were peeps raving over his most recent performance.

[Roger Mellie]

I saw this and thought of the TS.

[shade darkar]

Again, sub-moronic post.

It ahs nothing to do with being a "yank" (seriously will you idiots ever learn that Yank doesn't even mean American?). If so why do American's root for Mexcian fighters or Puerto Rican fighters? Hmmm?

Strange. And Floyd Mayweather is American and has plenty of American haters. On this board most people hate him. Strange when you think about how ****** your theory is....

mexican and peurto rican fighters are not european are they! hmmmmmm! what is my theory, i dont even know what the fcuk you are goin on about!

[IMDAZED]

wrong, im not even a calzaghe fan. try again. yeah, well the ts made it out that he was 40 and soooooo much older than calzaghe. if roy was so shot, which im not claiming he was or wasnt, then why were peeps raving over his most recent performance.

LMAO. Because it was a good performance against a shot, never-will-be. Not because they think he's still an elite fighter. ****, if Calzaghe's performance (getting up from an early KD to win a wide decision) should be given any due, what does that say about Glen Johnson beating Jones from pillar to post before putting him in a coma a full four years before? We've been through this already, enough. Even Calzaghe once said he wouldn't fight Jones because he was shot and finished.

[Lead Cenobite]

wrong, im not even a calzaghe fan. try again. yeah, well the ts made it out that he was 40 and soooooo much older than calzaghe. if roy was so shot, which im not claiming he was or wasnt, then why were peeps raving over his most recent performance.

Who was that performance over? Oh yeah, punching bag NEVER was SHOT lacy. Yup a guy that NEVER was being shot (so he was less than ****). Also who cares what morons rave about? Maybe you should be be more concerned with the facts and not fanboys creaming their pants over Roy humiliating a clown.

Fact is Roy was shot. And every post you made before this sounds like you were saying he wasn't, so just be a man and admit you think Joe beating up a shot as **** Roy was a GREAT win and we can move on. In terms of FIGHTING age Roy was SOOOOO Much older than Joe who had been in how many wars? Exactly. Roy was done after Tarver II. Double Done after Johnson 1. Retired for 2 years or so. QUIT against Tarver in III cause he was so done. RETIRED AGAIN. Came back beat up a shot blown up midget in Trinidad and 2 club fighters.

Joe meanwhile had derided Jones as "done" and "not worth fighting" and then when he way the easy payday took it because well-that's what Joe does. Now Joe says it was a great win and his idiot fans gobble it up. Awesome.

[Lead Cenobite]

mexican and peurto rican fighters are not european are they! hmmmmmm! what is my theory, i dont even know what the fcuk you are goin on about!

Oh so at first it was "non American" fighters, now it's Euros. Right. That's why everyone here "hates" Lennox Lewis gives him no respect or puts him in the ATG or best fighters of the last 20 years right?

Nice fail.

Now watch you make it about being white.

[shade darkar]

LMAO. Because it was a good performance against a shot, never-will-be. Not because they think he's still an elite fighter. ****, if Calzaghe's performance (getting up from an early KD to win a wide decision) should be given any due, what does that say about Glen Johnson beating Jones from pillar to post before putting him in a coma a full four years before? We've been through this already, enough. Even Calzaghe once said he wouldn't fight Jones because he was shot and finished.

i cant be arsed anymore! it seems to me that any fighter that isnt called manny pacman or floyd mayweather is an over rated, shot, past his prime fighter. why do people fail to realise that even if you are passed your best, if you are as good as jones was, then your still gonna be pretty good past your prime.

[IMDAZED]

i cant be arsed anymore! it seems to me that any fighter that isnt called manny pacman or floyd mayweather is an over rated, shot, past his prime fighter. why do people fail to realise that even if you are passed your best, if you are as good as jones was, then your still gonna be pretty good past your prime.

He was. Except we're not talking about him being past his prime, we're talking about him being finished. Finito. Done. Kaput.

[Roger Mellie]

We definitely need some more of these threads,and a few Mayweather ones would be nice too.