the fact that castillo beat mayweather does that affect his legacy

[razor.thin]

he will be in the hof he was prob the best or 2nd best lw of this decade and is listed here http://www.boxingscene.com/?m=show&id=22737 as #22 best lightweights of all time ... sounds pretty fcuking great to me ...

hasnt beaten enough top guys to be hof, if he wasnt robbed of mayweather win then he would be but casamayor,corrales and johnston = not hof.

[DikanRadeljak]

CASTILLO got robbed heavy in that fight.

LEDERMAN had CASTILLO ahead 5 points.

[Doctor_Tenma]

shame mayweather lost to him then.

He won in my opinion and gave him a rematch to prove he was the better guy.

[2120]

castillo beat mayweather in the 1st fight does this affect mayweathers legacy?

Even if castillo beat floyd the first time (he did) it still does not affect his legacy in my opinion

floyd took a immediate rematch with castillo and made the obvious adjustment

floyd learned from the first match that he needed to make the fight less compelling by exchanging less and moving all night to ensure a clear win for him over castillo the second time around

[Lead Cenobite]

CASTILLO got robbed heavy in that fight.

LEDERMAN had CASTILLO ahead 5 points.

Lederman and you can't score for ****.

[Doctor_Tenma]

Even if castillo beat floyd the first time (he did) it still does not affect his legacy in my opinion

floyd took a immediate rematch with castillo and made the obvious adjustment

floyd learned from the first match that he needed to make the fight less compelling by exchanging less and moving all night to ensure a clear win for him over castillo the second time around

What rematch?!

[razor.thin]

He won in my opinion and gave him a rematch to prove he was the better guy.

yes but in your opinion bernard hopkins is undefeated. biasy should not be involved in scoring fights.

[DikanRadeljak]

Lederman and you can't score for ****.

You like everyone else knows that CASTILLO won that fight.

[Doctor_Tenma]

yes but in your opinion bernard hopkins is undefeated. biasy should not be involved in scoring fights.

Listen to this guy, pure hater

[Lead Cenobite]

You like everyone else knows that CASTILLO won that fight.

Show me your scorecard. Round by round with commentary.

Or better yet name the scoring categories in order of importance for professional boxing. Also please explain to me how hitting the shoulders, arms, elbows, gloves and the back of the head count as scoring punches.

Thanks!