Would these guys be undefeated?

[[ DUBBZZ ]]

Pwill, Cotto, Pac, Mosley, Hatton
Which of these guys would be undefeated if they all of them took the same exact career path as Floyd's? (Same opponents, same time in their careers, etc)

[Doctor_Tenma]

Hard to say because you have to add weight into the equation. Also, do we have to factor in the more improved Pacquiao or not?

[baracuda]

except hatton yes......

[johncods]

i think hatton wont but the other 3 definitely would be undefeated..

[[ DUBBZZ ]]

except hatton yes......

I agree, he probably would've lost to Judah and Oscar

[larry x]

yea cause floyd hasnt fought anyone

[LEFTYGUNZZ]

Mr boat buyer took risks BITD. Only his WW res lacks. he did what he had to do at 130-135. He just been slackin at WW so long cats on here are startin to forget about that. It ain't like his whole career was cherrypickin.

Mosely maybe he has what 5 losses? 2 losses to Winky wright and 2 losses to Vernon Forrest. Than the one questionable loss to (I do not question it) in MSG. I honestly think Mosely would be undefeated if he took the same type of fights as Mayweather. PAC no because he lost by KO to stiffs before he learned how to use his right hand. Hatton has a shot up until Corrales and Marquez. Seeing how Floyd is older than Ricky right now I don't think Hatton will have much left in two years time. Especially the way he blows up and drinks in his off time. P Will could have never fought below 147 so lots of Mayweathers opposition was at 130-135lbs. Cotto might have a shot but I think Chico might give him trouble and maybe even Marquez even though Marquez is small for 140-147 Cotto gets hit and Marquez got a good style to beat Cotto....The question I propose is would Money Man Mayweather be undefeated if he fought the same paths as Mosely, PACMAN or Cotto?.....Lefty

[baracuda]

Mr boat buyer took risks BITD. Only his WW res lacks. he did what he had to do at 130-135. He just been slackin at WW so long cats on here are startin to forget about that. It ain't like his whole career was cherrypickin.

i dont think anyone forgets, i just dont think the corrales,genaros,jesus chavez,the jlc's,chop chop,gatti would beat shane , pac or cotto...

[[ DUBBZZ ]]

Mosely maybe he has what 5 losses? 2 losses to Winky wright and 2 losses to Vernon Forrest. Than the one questionable loss to (I do not question it) in MSG. I honestly think Mosely would be undefeated if he took the same type of fights as Mayweather. PAC no because he lost by KO to stiffs before he learned how to use his right hand. Hatton has a shot up until Corrales and Marquez. Seeing how Floyd is older than Ricky right now I don't think Hatton will have much left in two years time. Especially the way he blows up and drinks in his off time. P Will could have never fought below 147 so lots of Mayweathers opposition was at 130-135lbs. Cotto might have a shot but I think Chico might give him trouble and maybe even Marquez even though Marquez is small for 140-147 Cotto gets hit and Marquez got a good style to beat Cotto....The question I propose is would Money Man Mayweather be undefeated if he fought the same paths as Mosely, PACMAN or Cotto?.....Lefty

He would've beat Cotto easily. Win over Marg. Mosley? Not sure

[[ DUBBZZ ]]

Mosely maybe he has what 5 losses? 2 losses to Winky wright and 2 losses to Vernon Forrest. Than the one questionable loss to (I do not question it) in MSG. I honestly think Mosely would be undefeated if he took the same type of fights as Mayweather. PAC no because he lost by KO to stiffs before he learned how to use his right hand. Hatton has a shot up until Corrales and Marquez. Seeing how Floyd is older than Ricky right now I don't think Hatton will have much left in two years time. Especially the way he blows up and drinks in his off time. P Will could have never fought below 147 so lots of Mayweathers opposition was at 130-135lbs. Cotto might have a shot but I think Chico might give him trouble and maybe even Marquez even though Marquez is small for 140-147 Cotto gets hit and Marquez got a good style to beat Cotto....The question I propose is would Money Man Mayweather be undefeated if he fought the same paths as Mosely, PACMAN or Cotto?.....Lefty

Also, don't think he would've beat ODLH twice.