Whose resume is better? Floyd or Calzaghe?

[ELPacman]

I only ask since they are both undefeated. Calzaghe never claimed to be so great, but did fight some legends(when they were suppose to be dead), yet those legends are still winning right now. He even took the Jeff Lacy fight when Lacy was young and suppose to be highly dangerous(and undefeated also). Floyd has never fought a dangerous opponent, has never fought legendary opponents. Seriously, whose resume is better? Forget comparing him to Pac, I think he should be compared to Calzaghe since Floyd's only claim to greatness is really his 0, while Calzaghe also has an 0, has better names on his list, and doesn't claim to be that great.

[Syf]

Zags padded his record, imo, in the UK for far too long.

He started fighting good comp in the end, but Floyd consistently fought tougher competition overall...

That is, f you are looking at both of their full careers, and not just Floyd's WW resume like 99% of NSB does...

[The Underboss]

Floyd:


Corrales
Castillo
Gatti
Baldomir
Judah
DLH
Hatton
Marquez

Calzaghe:

Eubank (only famous in the UK)
Lacy
Kessler
Hopkins (bull**** decision)
Jones

Floyd has the more superior resume

[Freddy Krueger]

Floyd:


Corrales
Castillo
Gatti
Baldomir
Judah
DLH
Hatton
Marquez

Calzaghe:

Eubank (only famous in the UK)
Lacy
Kessler
Hopkins (bull**** decision)
Jones

Floyd has the more superior resume

Should have been Dq'd for excessive holding, either way the right man won that fight in my opinion. Bull**** decision? LOL, weren't all three judges Americans? And the fight basically took place in Hopkins backyard in America!

[alza1988]

I just watched this video .Mayweather talking about Hopkins .He beat DelaHoya which was a small man. Trinidad Wright small men .When he did fight somebody his own weight he got beat by Roy Jones .He got beat by the guy from the UK .What's his name Interviewer Calzaghe .Mayweather .Calzaghe he got beat by Calzaghe .25.30

http://www.skysports.com/video/inline/0,26691,13273_5700132,00.html

It's funny how some of the American fighters hardly sound as if they know some of the fighters from the UK
.Well I can think of 2 anyway Mayweather and Tyson like he hardly knows Haye.

[Pullcounter]

I only ask since they are both undefeated. Calzaghe never claimed to be so great, but did fight some legends(when they were suppose to be dead), yet those legends are still winning right now. He even took the Jeff Lacy fight when Lacy was young and suppose to be highly dangerous(and undefeated also). Floyd has never fought a dangerous opponent, has never fought legendary opponents. Seriously, whose resume is better? Forget comparing him to Pac, I think he should be compared to Calzaghe since Floyd's only claim to greatness is really his 0, while Calzaghe also has an 0, has better names on his list, and doesn't claim to be that great.

calz's resume by far is much more horrible