Does Miguel Cotto deserve to be Mentioned amongst the PR Greats?

[Dondi33O]

Does Miguel Cotto deserve to be Mentioned amongst the PR Greats?
Simple question. No hate.
Personally, and I am a big fan of his. I think not. I believe he was on the cusp and did not finish.
Who is to say in the future it can still happen but as of now I say no.

[ianblake]

CLARO QUE SI, top 10

[Bretty Poy32]

hes not even retired yet

[Bushbaby]

He has more boxing skill than Trinidad,so by that alone he should be up there!!

[Dondi33O]

He has more boxing skill than Trinidad,so by that alone he should be up there!!

Personally I think its about who you beat not all on your skill. Mike Tyson was no Ali but KOed enough to be a great.

[The Gully Gad]

All i know is he aint no Felix Trinidad...

[Bushbaby]

Personally I think its about who you beat not all on your skill. Mike Tyson was no Ali but KOed enough to be a great.

Cotto did a number at 140-147!!Tito's biggest win at 147 was kinda um,not really what happened,in that fight!!

[Shattered Jaw]

It's a hard question. Trinidad versus Mosely and (plastered up) Cheato would have been a spectacle that's for sure.

[Kevin Jesus]

Top 25 def but not top 10.

[Glamour Puss]

No. Not after losing to Packy like that.