Ok, we all know Pernell really beat Chavez

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Vasyl’s dad
    He said no rematch
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Mar 2008
    • 23510
    • 1,120
    • 1,945
    • 50,072

    #1

    Ok, we all know Pernell really beat Chavez

    but how many of you wouldn't call Pea the rightful champion had the correct decision been announced?

    Remember, this fight had a cap of 145 lbs to it as well.

    So, how many of you willing to say Pac didn't really win the championship because of the catchweight are willing to do the same for Whitaker. I understand Pea was defending his title whereas Pac was going for one, but the premise is still the same.


    Let it be known that I wasn't fond of the catch weight stipulations either, but seeing as it didn't affect the outcome any I don't see why it should be a problem.

    Yea I believe a true championship should be won at the normal weight,

    but its not like this is the first time its happened.

    So, had the correct decision been announced in the Pea Chavez bout,

    would you object to Pernell being called "champion"?
  • -MAKAVELLI-
    Banned
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Aug 2008
    • 50080
    • 3,580
    • 2,792
    • 169,000

    #2
    Originally posted by Tapatio
    but how many of you wouldn't call Pea the rightful champion had the correct decision been announced?

    Remember, this fight had a cap of 145 lbs to it as well.

    So, how many of you willing to say Pac didn't really win the championship because of the catchweight are willing to do the same for Whitaker. I understand Pea was defending his title whereas Pac was going for one, but the premise is still the same.


    Let it be known that I wasn't fond of the catch weight stipulations either, but seeing as it didn't affect the outcome any I don't see why it should be a problem.

    Yea I believe a true championship should be won at the normal weight,

    but its not like this is the first time its happened.

    So, had the correct decision been announced in the Pea Chavez bout,

    would you object to Pernell being called "champion"?




    so was the ole lady happy on saturday gallo? what goes up, kept goin up

    Comment

    • Vasyl’s dad
      He said no rematch
      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
      • Mar 2008
      • 23510
      • 1,120
      • 1,945
      • 50,072

      #3
      Originally posted by Makavelli
      so was the ole lady happy on saturday gallo? what goes up, kept goin up
      lol, she was excited!

      She was very in touch with her Asian side that night.

      I told her, "fool, you're part Korean not Filipino"

      she says, "so what, its close enough, I can claim him"

      Comment

      • -MAKAVELLI-
        Banned
        Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
        • Aug 2008
        • 50080
        • 3,580
        • 2,792
        • 169,000

        #4
        Originally posted by Tapatio
        lol, she was excited!

        She was very in touch with her Asian side that night.

        I told her, "fool, you're part Korean not Filipino"

        she says, "so what, its close enough, I can claim him"


        hahahahaha!!! f'n classic...any fan of excitement can claim him

        Comment

        Working...
        TOP