Is Cotto a HOF'er?

[jrosales13]

Will Cotto be in the hall of fame?

If no, why whats missing from his resume?

If yes, why?

[ThePunchingBag]

He has a good chance if he beats Margarito, FMJ, Berto, and Mosley(again).

[Chups]

Not yet.



...........

[JM1]

his hall of fame career started last night. he needs to continue fighting the best and that will be to his advantage. i cant wait to see him back

[Silencers]

I think he falls just a little bit short right now, the win against Mosley was really really good but he fell short in 2 of his biggest fights, the fights against Margarito (suspect wraps or not) and the fight against Pacquiao, he was on the cusp before both fights. He still has time to get himself in though.

[Freddy Krueger]

Cotto:

Mosley
Clottey
Quintana
Torres
Judah

[Shadows]

He's not there yet. He does have some good names on his resume, but I think the fact that he won vacant belts and he lost his two biggest fights take some luster away.

Welterweight is deep and he may not have it anymore to get the top of the division. IMO he's too small for 154.

I think he may end up like Casamayor and Castillo and just fall a little short.

[MOTHER DUCKER]

No.. An old Mosley is his biggest win (was hardly dominant) was lucky it was in MSG

Judah? everyone had beaten him by the time Cotto got to him..

Quintana? B class WW at best

Clottey? another home win for Cotto

[JM1]

he may not be there yet, but im sure hes getting there someday

[Iceta]

Does Cotto deserve to be in the HOF? In my opinion, fuck no. Will he get in there? Probably.