Is Manny beating a 29 yr old Cotto more impressive then anything Mayweather Jr did?

[-EX-]

If this was before Cotto lost to Margarito I'd say yes without a doubt...but I'd put it on par with Floyd beating Corrales...

[jrosales13]

I give the edge to Cotto over Corrales just cuz that was Floyd natural weightclass. This was not Pac natural weightclass. And, I still don't think Floyd has beat anybody that is even as good as Barrera.

[josenoway]

man people have some short ass memories, the mayweather corrales fight was equally as impressive, if not more. Chico had people ****ting bricks in fear, and Floyd went in there and just tore the taller, bigger guy a new *******. I mean, he absolutely desecrated Chico.

[Puya]

I voted yes

[Freddy Krueger]

If this was before Cotto lost to Margarito I'd say yes without a doubt...but I'd put it on par with Floyd beating Corrales...

I still don't believe Margarito won that fight fairly.