Who should be considered p4p #1: Floyd or Manny?

[Idgas]

wow look at those results.

[K-Nan]

Manny Pacquiao, no question.

[1toTHADOME]

Pacquiao of course. Floyd aint doing **** right now. And for those who picked floyd, you guys are so much in denial. i dont know how you can say Floyd's the best when he's not even fighting the best while Pacquiao is making it look so easy winning over the best.

[KESSLER]

I'm gonna go with Pacquiao on this one, even though Floyd is one of my favorites. I don't really like Pacquiao, but I respect what he has done and what he is doing.

[Easy-E]

I think Floyd is a better p4p fighter, but Manny, given his activity and recent performances, should be considered number one pound for pound.

[The Hammer]

I think Floyd is a better p4p fighter

Why?

Floyd won a close decision over De La Hoya (many thought it was a gift), while Pacquiao destroyed Oscar.

Floyd had a tough fight for the first six rounds against Hatton, and KOed him late with the help of the corner ring pillar. He had a home referee helping him as well. Pacquiao knocked down Hatton twice in round one and then out cold in round two!

Floyd ducked Miguel Cotto, while Manny fights him and dominates!

Floyd started at 130, while Manny started at 106 and was world champion at 112 as a teenager. Floyd is a naturally much bigger man, Manny could still be fighting at lightweight.

Easy-E, I know you have a ****sexual infatuation with Floyd, but there should be NO DOUBT WHATSOVER who the best p4p fighter in the world is.

[syphillis]

I think Floyd is a better p4p fighter, but Manny, given his activity and recent performances, should be considered number one pound for pound.

I think Floyd is the better boxer, Pac the better fighter. This fight needs to be made.

[Easy-E]

Why?

Floyd won a close decision over De La Hoya (many thought it was a gift), while Pacquiao destroyed Oscar.

Floyd had a tough fight for the first six rounds against Hatton, and KOed him late with the help of the corner ring pillar. He had a home referee helping him as well. Pacquiao knocked down Hatton twice in round one and then out cold in round two!

Floyd ducked Miguel Cotto, while Manny fights him and dominates!

Floyd started at 130, while Manny started at 106 and was world champion at 112 as a teenager.

Easy-E, I know you have huge ****sexual infatuation with Floyd, but there should be NO DOUBT WHATSOVER who the best p4p fighter in the world is.

I think Floyd would beat Manny if they fought.
Anyone who thought DLH vs Mayweather was ever close has no idea how to score fights.
I said I think Floyd is a better fighter than Manny but Manny has accomplished more and deserves the be considered p4p number 1.

Your insults are getting stale, Tunney.

[shade darkar]

Who do you think is the best p4p fighter in boxing, Floyd Mayweather Jr or Manny Pacquiao?

right now its gotta be pacquiao. mayweather hasnt fought anybody in the last 2 years except marquez who he got to weigh in for a 144lb bout and then came in overweight, as if it wasnt enough already that he was coming up from lightweight. ***** move. where as pacquiao is fighting champions at their own weights, and demolishing anything put in front of him. its not even close in my opinion.

[Easy-E]

I think Floyd is the better boxer, Pac the better fighter. This fight needs to be made.

When I say that Floyd is better, I mean I would favor him in a matchup between the two.
But between his retirement, and Manny's amazing performances of late, hes number one on the list.