That win makes PAcman at top 50 ATG

[El Jesus]

thing is Roy as good as he is, never beat any ATGs himself, outside of a younger more inexperienced BHop at the time

he also beat a young experienced james toney and humiliated him.

regardless, i think pac is definately within the top 15 fighters of the sport, a win over mayweather would put him into top 10 company. how you rate him depends on this. do you like fighters who clean out a division, or do you like a fighter whos grabbed the top of each division, it depends and its a good debate to have.

[rawr]

He is not top 10 yet, jeez you guys cant take a complement...

co sign...

[Easy-E]

Pacman has officially become the second greatest fighter in my lifetime, right behind Roy.

If pacman beats Floyd he is top 20 maybe a top 10, no if, ands, or buts.


Congratz Pacman, and congratz Cotto for the fight.

Im not going to make any decisions about Pac until he retires.
I mean if he beats Floyd he shows hes about 80, if he beats him, about top 20. Its ****** to try and determine a fighters ranking until their career has been completed.

[Nautilus]

I am sorry, but I do not think Roy is an ATG.

[Easy-E]

thing is Roy as good as he is, never beat any ATGs himself, outside of a younger more inexperienced BHop at the time

Hop and Toney.
Pac beats some ATG's in Morales, Barrera and DLH, but all were late late late in their carrer, with the exception of Barrera I.

[joartcc5]

Pacman has officially become the second greatest fighter in my lifetime, right behind Roy.

If pacman beats Floyd he is top 20 maybe a top 10, no if, ands, or buts.


Congratz Pacman, and congratz Cotto for the fight.

top 5 ATG....

[cyutetrick]

yea its hard to argue against 7 world titles at 7 different weight classes i think he has to be considered a top 10 now.

[jrosales13]

Pacman has officially become the second greatest fighter in my lifetime, right behind Roy.

If pacman beats Floyd he is top 20 maybe a top 10, no if, ands, or buts.


Congratz Pacman, and congratz Cotto for the fight.

Pac is already a greater fighter than Roy. Roy I have never heard of an ATG fighter not be able to win at least 1 lineal title.

Pac is top 30 fighter for sure already. Maybe, maybe, argubly top 25 of all time.

And, Pac has to beat Floyd and the winner of Shane-Berto just to be in the top 15. He would still need to do a lot more to get that top 10 spot.

[jrosales13]

top 5 ATG....

Please tell me you not serious.

[-EX-]

He was already top 50...I think you can make an argument for top 25-30 definently...

I don't know about top 20...anything over top 15-20 isn't right IMO...