Will Mayweather achieve Ring Mag. P4P #1 with Cotto victory?

[Stab Judah]

Trinidad was fighter of the year in 2000 i'm pretty sure he was p4p#1 for a very short span with Hopkins taking over and then Roy getting it back by beating Ruiz.

[..WaRSpencE..]

To the TS..can you please remove that sig?..

I wanna gag everytime I see that ****..I don't mind feet..but not in my face like that..that's some sick festish bro..just saying..make that **** your wallpaper and screensaver or something..and save us the nausea..

[Iceta]

Here is the answer. Fuck to the no if I had anything to do with the way they do their rankings. Floyd is the king cherry picker.

[Bobby_Manila]

No, he is currently a 140lb'r who has gone up to fight the 147lb champ.

the 147lb'r SHOULD win.

That's like saying John Ruiz was fighting a 160 pounder in Toney. If Toney made heavyweight, he's heavyweight.

If Pacquiao makes WW, he's WW.

It seems there is a double standard for Mayweather. If he fights #2 spot, he gets #2 spot. If someone fights and beats #1 spot... Floyd gets #1 spot.

[Marijuana]

Maybe because P4P #1 is fighting at WW right now, and one of the WW champions is fighting him at that weight class.

So if Floyd went up to MW to fight Pavlik instead of fighting Hatton in late 2008, and lost, Pavlik should have been P4P #1?

[sycomantz]

hes already P4P#1

thats why Cotto and Pac are fighting for a ultrafight with May. hes not fighting for a shotat them. that says what their positions and ranking ares

[NakiFan]

To the TS..can you please remove that sig?..

I wanna gag everytime I see that ****..I don't mind feet..but not in my face like that..that's some sick festish bro..just saying..make that **** your wallpaper and screensaver or something..and save us the nausea..

I agree, I like to go on boxingscene at work and if my co-workers see that they gonna think i'm a weirdie, i dont care what you do in you own time but please don't subject us to it.

[Bobby_Manila]

So if Floyd went up to MW to fight Pavlik instead of fighting Hatton in late 2008, and lost, Pavlik should have been P4P #1?

Had Floyd beaten Abraham and Taylor before, of course.

You seem to forget Manny made Oscar stay sit at 145 and KTFO'd Hatton at 140.
Oh, yes, I forgot "but Oscar was dehydrated/shot/sick and Hatton was overrated".

Isn't P4P exactly that? That if you are P4P the best, once you make weight, you clean out a division because - Pound for Pound - no one can match you?

[baracuda]

look, weve had our battles in the past but surely you cant beleive that Cotto deserves to be #1 with a Pac victory. I know you arent crazy enough to beleive that. Even if its not Floyd, there are definatly other guys ahead of Cotto but it should be without a doubt, Mayweather

i believe that 100%....cotto's # 4 now fighting the #1 in pac.....floyd was'nt in the p4p when he fought jmm who was # 2 at that time.....if cotto beats pac he desrves to be # 1....

[Marijuana]

Had Floyd beaten Abraham and Taylor before, of course.

You seem to forget Manny made Oscar stay sit at 145 and KTFO'd Hatton at 140.
Oh, yes, I forgot "but Oscar was dehydrated/shot/sick and Hatton was overrated".

Isn't P4P exactly that? That if you are P4P the best, once you make weight, you clean out a division because - Pound for Pound - no one can match you?

No pound for pound is, if everyone was the same weight, height, size, etc. etc., who would win based on their skill set.

The answer to that question is Floyd Mayweather Jr.