P4P Rankings after Nov 14

[koboy]

If Manny wins, he'll obviously still be No. 1. What if he loses, where would you rank him?

If Cotto wins, where would he land in your P4P list? And if he loses?

Thoughts.

[Klitschko2010]

My list would be as follows if Cotto won:

1) Paul Williams
2) Adamek
3) Cotto
4) Pacquiao
5) Mosely
6) Dawson
7) Abraham
8) Froch
9) Bradely
10) Vitali Klishscko

[dde91]

Well They would obviously put Gayweather Number 1 if he loses because they want to give mayweather everything so he could fight again
And Pacquiao would drop to 2 maybe 3
And Cotto could be number 2 or number 4. Because he did beat Mosley and Mosley is top 10 already.

[dde91]

My list would be as follows if Cotto won:

1) Paul Williams
2) Adamek
3) Cotto
4) Pacquiao
5) Mosely
6) Dawson
7) Abraham
8) Froch
9) Bradely
10) Vitali Klishscko

adamek? Bradley? lol
Paul williams is p4p and will probably be p4p number 1 in a couple years but right now he doesn't have the resume to be number 1

adamek just beat a 40 year old former champ. And Bradley is going to lose to peterson plus he hasn't beaten a elite figher in my book.

[onedream722]

depends how the fight goes...one can drop more so if they are completely dominated

[Klitschko2010]

adamek? Bradley? lol
Paul williams is p4p and will probably be p4p number 1 in a couple years but right now he doesn't have the resume to be number 1

adamek just beat a 40 year old former champ. And Bradley is going to lose to peterson plus he hasn't beaten a elite figher in my book.

Williams is an absolute animal. I don't see how people can put him below Cotto/Mayweather etc when they could all make 147 and we all know who the winner would be.

Adamek is one of the best fighters of the last decade. Stop looking at a fighter's last fight only. Bradely is stalwardly cleaning up 140 pounds, good on him.

[Pullcounter]

if cotto wins, cotto is top 5 and manny is still in top 5 however lower than cotto. both will not be #1.... that will be gayweather

[JakeNDaBox]

Williams is an absolute animal. I don't see how people can put him below Cotto/Mayweather etc when they could all make 147 and we all know who the winner would be.

Adamek is one of the best fighters of the last decade. Stop looking at a fighter's last fight only. Bradely is stalwardly cleaning up 140 pounds, good on him.

I agree that Adamek deserves more credit than he's generally given, but it's impossible to offer a legitimate argument that he deserves to be rated higher than Chad Dawson on any P4P list.

If his CW resume were that impeccable, I could see it. But I'm not sure I believe that beating Steve Cunningham (and I guess O'Neil Bell, albeit a worn out version) trumps what Chad's accomplished to date.

As for the rest of your list - "no comment"

[dde91]

Williams is an absolute animal. I don't see how people can put him below Cotto/Mayweather etc when they could all make 147 and we all know who the winner would be.

Adamek is one of the best fighters of the last decade. Stop looking at a fighter's last fight only. Bradely is stalwardly cleaning up 140 pounds, good on him.

i mean Adamek is a p4p fighter, but his resume shouldn't make him higher then dawson when he lost to him and i could see him maybe from 10-8 p4p

And Bradley isn't cleaning up nothing.

[Nuurzhaelan]

I don't think if Cotto beats Pacquiao it will auto make him p4p 1. It will improve his standing, but that's not what he's fighting for.