If Pacquaio wins, will Floyd fans agree that he is P4P #1?

[Scary]

There's no doubt that he is not cherrypicking his opponent, he's fighting the best out there. Floyd isn't.

Based on resume, who's P4P #1 now?

[Scary]

Please state your reason.

[WhoreUs]

No they won't.
Their hero is.
He was #1 already...you know, before he quit.
He came back and beat the LW champ at WW.
He gets the most PPV buys.
He would win any fight, against any fighter, from any era.
He's so Flashy, he can't make JWW, but is too small to fight WW's.
He beat the Big Show.
He is their p4p #1 for life.

[Syf]

I have Pac #1 before the Cotto fight on my list..

Winning against Cotto would only cement that further.

Floyd is a solid # 2 for me on my p4p list

[h2k]

I agree. He's already my #1 lb4lb when may retire.

[Ravishing]

He'd be fighter of the decade in my book.

He isn't necessarily fighting the low-tier of the division. Cotto and Mosley are both arguably the #1 WWs. No question you'd have to give him the nod. Plus, he would've beaten 2 guys Floyd fought AND 1 that Floyd never fought.

**** an undefeated record truthfully, everyone will look at this on a higher pedestal than Floyd's record. Quote me on that.

[2501]

they should, they've already admitted that..

Exactly, skills win fights not weight.

[The Gambler1981]

I am fine with him number 1 now, out of all the guys on most lists Manny was really the one that did big things to maintain his position, Cotto would just add to that if he wins.

There is no right answer in the first place there is no set criteria for P4P, it is all about opinion and what someone is looking for.