if cotto wins should/would he be fighter of the year?

[-Boxzilla-]

manny's a lock if he wins ... how bout cotto? simple question yes or no.

if no who then?

[JCO]

Either him or Vitali.

[MetalVomit]

whoever wins that fight will probably get fighter of the year

[Bobby_Manila]

Yes.

And Pac Man fighter of the Decade.

[savorduhflavor]

Yes. He will and he should.

[Animalistic 5.0]

3-0 with wins over Pacquiao, Clottey and Jennings should be enough to get fighter of the year IMO.

[Freddy Krueger]

Either him or Vitali.

Vitali will never get fighter of the year because he is so skillful and talented that he makes almost every opponent he fight look like a fool. The Klitschkos are very talented and underrated by some ppl. Meaning that the fighters they fight are better then what ppl realize, but its just that Klitschkos are that talented to make it look easy.

[Iceta]

Only if he really wins unlike he did against Clottey and Mosley.

[baracuda]

yes, he should...

[Freddy Krueger]

Only if he really wins unlike he did against Clottey and Mosley.

Clottey should have been Dq'd for headbutting. And he clearly beat Mosley dumb ass, he jabbed Mosley to death. I had it like 8-4 in a competitive fight.