What if.....Cotto beats Pacquiao and Mayweather

[Pullcounter]

would that make him an ATG? is he already an ATG? would he rank higher than floyd and manny?

not sure... cotto's resume is good, but he needs to give mosley, clottey, and margo rematches and he has to win them so convincingly that no one will doubt it.

[mellow_mood]

not sure... cotto's resume is good, but he needs to give mosley, clottey, and margo rematches and he has to win them so convincingly that no one will doubt it.

I agee with mosley... because what his name carries...


not to clottey or margie though

[taino78]

not sure... cotto's resume is good, but he needs to give mosley, clottey, and margo rematches and he has to win them so convincingly that no one will doubt it.

who the **** ever beat shane or clottey convincingly. gtfo

[project xxx1]

not sure... cotto's resume is good, but he needs to give mosley, clottey, and margo rematches and he has to win them so convincingly that no one will doubt it.

are you being serious?

[P.WILL]

not sure... cotto's resume is good, but he needs to give mosley, clottey, and margo rematches and he has to win them so convincingly that no one will doubt it.

i had cotto-mosley 116-112 for Cotto 8 rounds to 4
i think thats convincing
however i had him beating clottey by 1 point and would not have argued if they gave the fight to clottey

[blind4]

he would be P 4 P #1 that's for sure

[Moderator]

Hatton > Morales > Cotto

[project xxx1]

would that make him an ATG? is he already an ATG? would he rank higher than floyd and manny?

of course he would.anyone who beats pbf 1st willl derserve it

[Bobby_Manila]

would that make him an ATG? is he already an ATG? would he rank higher than floyd and manny?

To secure a good ranking among the ATGs Cotto needs to:

A) Beat Pacquiao by KO. Otherwise, Pacquiao wins more respect than him (like Duran/Hagler).

B) Avenge his only loss.

C) Win one fight where he is expected to get KTFO. Paul Williams comes to mind.

[Aracibo04]

who the **** ever beat shane or clottey convincingly. gtfo

right, thats the issue i got with his comment.
manny ATG's have had wins that where not so convincing.