IMHO – A Cure for Boxing’s Big-Week Ills

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • BIGPOPPAPUMP
    Franchise Champion
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Sep 2003
    • 46539
    • 2,259
    • 334
    • 5,493,285

    #1

    IMHO – A Cure for Boxing’s Big-Week Ills

    By Lyle Fitzsimmons - It’s another big fight week. Which means different things to different people.

    Especially we writer types.

    Some count down to opening bells by waxing nostalgic on past events. Some immerse in head-to-head matchups seeking evidence of one man’s superiority. And others simply spend time gorging on hospitality food and drink buffets.

    Not a bad selection in the bunch… if you ask me.

    But I come here not to praise the fistic establishment, but to bury it.

    And, while simultaneously pondering replies to a Facebook friend request from someone I’ve neither seen in about 20 years nor liked in about 21, I’m feeling just a tad bit crusadery.

    Either that or it’s another mid-life crisis.

    And though no one’s asked my opinion in so many words, I’ve nonetheless chosen this week to climb on the soapbox and enlighten with my own home remedy for boxing’s ills.

    My personal sanctioning body, if you will.

    For lack of a better idea, and because all the good ones are taken, we’ll keep our name simple.

    Ladies and gentlemen… I present the IMHO.

    Of course, with the arrival of a supreme being of sanctioning bodies all the others must immediately be dissolved. So with apologies to their office-bound hierarchies and corporate staffs, I bid adieu to the IBF, IBO, WBA, WBC and WBO.

    Not to mention The Ring.

    Sorry Oscar, you’ve been downsized.

    Or if you prefer, voted off alphabet island.

    Next, I hereby declare all existing championships vacant. [details]
  • antrob
    Undisputed Champion
    • Jun 2009
    • 1236
    • 53
    • 88
    • 7,403

    #2
    Please don't count the IBO as one of the "main" belts. And how is Adamek not the cruiserweight champion and how is Floyd Mayweather the welterweight champion in your "alphabelt" organzation. Damn this is what it come down to that i even have to complain about a make believe alphabelt title.

    Comment

    • ivorycoast
      Amateur
      Interim Champion - 1-100 posts
      • Nov 2008
      • 6
      • 0
      • 0
      • 6,035

      #3
      Your system has flaws...

      I've played around with a similar idea that what if there would be just one... But man you already presented there the problem of having putting together the rankings since you got some wild names as number one... Like the writer before me mentioned Adamed missing at cruiser and MAyweather number one at welterweight??? Come on man with what merits ? Really in welterweight...
      And on top of the cake you got Froch at number one in super middleweight, the guy with a gritty attitude and that's all... His about to be exposed fully in Super Six ( well his lucked out a win in his last two but it's bound to end ... )

      Ok that kind of mini-tournament thing would show the right picking order for the time but for the future there would be still similar problems in rankings when for-whatever-reason some guys would be raised to the pedestal and some be just dismissed...

      Comment

      • Lacrimosa
        I am betman!
        Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
        • Apr 2009
        • 1364
        • 53
        • 206
        • 7,755

        #4
        Originally posted by antrob
        Please don't count the IBO as one of the "main" belts. And how is Adamek not the cruiserweight champion and how is Floyd Mayweather the welterweight champion in your "alphabelt" organzation. Damn this is what it come down to that i even have to complain about a make believe alphabelt title.
        I guess Adamek vacated his CW title and is now fighting as a full-time HW???

        Yeah, i agree - Floyd as the top WW is a joke Same about Froch as a top SMW...

        Comment

        • fitzbitz
          Up and Comer
          Interim Champion - 1-100 posts
          • Sep 2008
          • 45
          • 8
          • 0
          • 6,117

          #5
          Check the computer...

          As I pointed out in the piece, guys, the No. 1 seeds I listed are based on the computer rankings as of Nov. 1. The only change I made was to eliminate Adamek at cruiser, because he's now fighting at heavy. Cunningham was listed No. 2. Now he's No. 1. All the others - Froch and Mayweather in particular - come from the unbiased computer. Do I agree with all of them? No. But that's part of the beauty of it.

          Comment

          • fitzbitz
            Up and Comer
            Interim Champion - 1-100 posts
            • Sep 2008
            • 45
            • 8
            • 0
            • 6,117

            #6
            As for the IBO being a main belt... I believe it is. Or at least that it ought to be. I believe they have the best ratings system. And they are the only body recognizing either Chad Dawson or Manny Pacquiao as a world champion. Are all their guys gold? Heck no. But all of the organizations have champions that you look at and say, "huh?" To me, they have the best jumping-off point, which is the ratings. Beyond that, what it takes is building legitimacy. And if writers/observers would stop buying into the other bodies with all their flaws, then maybe the IBO could get traction. Otherwise, as I'm suggesting in the piece, we ought to just scrap them all and start fresh.

            Comment

            • edgarg
              Honest BoxingScene posts
              Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
              • Dec 2004
              • 11045
              • 547
              • 54
              • 39,228

              #7
              Query

              What do you mean .... Yuri Foreman #1 champion??

              Also, Mayweather is not the champion welterweight;he has yet to fight a live 147 lb er.

              Mosley is the Welterweight Champion.....or Cotto, but not Mayweather.

              Comment

              • fitzbitz
                Up and Comer
                Interim Champion - 1-100 posts
                • Sep 2008
                • 45
                • 8
                • 0
                • 6,117

                #8
                My bad...

                Yuri Foreman should say No. 1 contender, not champion.

                As for the Mayweather questions, etc... again, the inaugural champions list is based on the computer's rankings, not mine. The guys listed are each ranked No. 1 in their respective divisions. It's not necessarily reflective of my opinion. In some cases, yes. In others, no.

                Comment

                • antrob
                  Undisputed Champion
                  • Jun 2009
                  • 1236
                  • 53
                  • 88
                  • 7,403

                  #9
                  By the way computer ranking aren't always the best just look at the BCS in college football.

                  Comment

                  • Jamel H
                    Undisputed Champion
                    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                    • Sep 2009
                    • 1130
                    • 51
                    • 0
                    • 10,843

                    #10
                    Originally posted by edgarg
                    What do you mean .... Yuri Foreman #1 champion??

                    Also, Mayweather is not the champion welterweight;he has yet to fight a live 147 lb er.

                    Mosley is the Welterweight Champion.....or Cotto, but not Mayweather.
                    Mayweather doesnt even hold a single BELT there period lol but like he said hes going off based November computer ratings

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP