If Manny beats Cotto, is he top 5 ATG???

[Ido]

If he can beat Moesly and Mayweather yes. Just Cotto, No.

[CrackYourJaw]

He has beaten greats like Barrera, Morales, DLH, JMM and if he beats the MUCH bigger COTTO?? Although overrated, Hatton was still considered a good fighter.

Nope.

He has to do more than that to be top 5 I would imagine.

[Bogler]

so if mosley is a must to push him into the top5 ATG, then i wonder why floyd doesnt want to fight him and why floyd fans here are justifying it. i could probably understand that floyd does what he does and fight whoever he fights aside from mosley as long as he gets money, but the floyd fans?

[-EX-]

No


...

[S.G.]

Nah man, I don't think he can ever reach that high with the opponents available to him.

[go1nbanana]

Add p williams to the list of mayweather and mosely, and he would be top 5 ATG...hahaha...our generation gives hard time to our own generation of fighter

[Chups]

No.




------------------

[Roger Mellie]

I dont think so. It is of course hypothetical,the real time to look at this question will be a few years after his retirement. History has a habit of being kind to high achievers.