Who was more exciting and impressive: Vitali vs. Arreola, or Haye vs Valuev?

[The Hammer]

Well obviously Vitali, but what did you want Haye to do? He fought in a way to utilize his advantages which are speed and mobility. Tunney, will you at least admit Haye stunning Valuev was impressive all things considered?

Either Klitschko would have stopped him.

But now that Valuev is just a contender instead of a titleholder, we may finally see a Klitschko vs. Valuev.

[mathed]

I'd say Vitali but you should compare the situations here. One guy was mismatched by height at a foot disadvantage and weight by nearly 100 lbs. The other guy had the height advantage at several inches and the weight disadvantage by 30 or so pounds while being the naturally bigger, quicker, stronger man.

Haye was a Cruiserweight fighting the biggest Heavyweight of ALL TIME. Vitali was a dominant Heavyweight fighting a LightHeavyweight who moved up. There are some differences here and also, Vitali was running with his back turned to get away from Arreola too. They both looked pretty bad winniing but Vitali looked better at it against a smaller guy.

[Best User Ever]

Haye vs. Valuev was like watching two ******s ****

[The Hammer]

Haye vs. Valuev was like watching two ******s ****

The slow, lumbering giant chased the chicken around the ring.

[T-97]

Vitali was more exciting, and it was a more dominant performance. But he wasn't giving away that much height, weight and reach.

[Derranged_]

Both rubbish fights. Both equally as bad really.

Really, Vitali fought like a champion and punished the challenger the whole fight and got the KO. How is that rubbish, Paul?..

[The Hammer]

Really, Vitali fought like a champion and punished the challenger the whole fight and got the KO. How is that rubbish, Paul?..

Paul hates Vitali because he dominated and stopped the love of his life, JC Gomez.

[Chunk..]

Both fights where good examples of the 'Sweet Science'.

[Sergio Martinez]

Of course Vitali......

[NakiFan]

Obviously Vitali, and so he should have been.

Come on Tunney you are better than this.