Is PBF a G.O.A.T or a DUCK?

[COACH WEBB]

Strugler, we get the point, you are not a Mayweather fan, so WHY do you make sooooo many threads about him and dedicate so much of your time towards him, that makes no sense. True Story. It has gotten old. There is a big fight coming up in two weeks, talk about that.

[sycomantz]

only to **** on him... that's not validation, that's humiliation.

the fact that you cant go without talking about him sure is validation. and as long as you talk about him, he is

[Grand Champ]

He's one of the most talented but too afraid of serious risks.

[Nuurzhaelan]

poll to follow????......................

That is quite a chasm. I believe he could be an all time great, but I don't think he rises to the level of GoAT or 'duck'...whatever duck means.

[strugler]

ok he is an ATG .....................but he's still a duck..........a damn loud one too

[Don Johnson]

nobody thinks hes the GOAT, hes no doubt an atg based on what he did at the lower weights though. and weather you like it or not, the guys he fought at the higher weight were the top guys at that time.

Gatti, Judah, Baldomir, De La hoya, Sharmba Mitchell, and Corley were definitely not top guys. There were better fighters around the time they fought Floyd.