how would prime/fit toney do in the fab 4 era?

[Freddy Krueger]

True, all very skilful fighters, but James himself is up there with the very best technically.

Toney left behind a good division missing out on fighters like Watson, Eubank, and Benn. He can say those fighters all avoided him but I have a hunch that he could have gotten those fights if he pushed a bit harder at them... Or I could be wrong and maybe someone was avoiding someone. I don't know whos stories to believe though...

[THE REED]

oxymoron if i ever heard one

[strugler]

Bump.........

[Joe2608]

He'd give anyone trouble, James Toney at Middleweight was a beast. I'd have him definatley win against Duran and probably Hearns, though i think it would be close. I think SRL would dance around to a decision and Hagler would be a tough fight too.

[bojangles1987]

Hagler would win a 8-4 type decision, wouldn't be too threatened.

Leonard would do about the same.

Duran would get countered all night and lose a big decision.

Not sure about Hearns, I'll say Toney wins a great fight by decision.