better resume, cotto or hatton?

[revs1227]

the hatton hate on this site will never stop its sickkk

[Grimmer]

Hatton:

Kostya Tzsyu
Carlos Maussa
Collazo
JLC
Mallignagi


Cotto:

Torres
Mallignagi
Quintana
Judah
Mosley



I was going to say Hatton...but after enumerating their opponents...I'm going to say Cotto.

Cotto did beat both Maussa and Malignaggi before Hatton and took both their "0"s. And for some people neither will make Cotto's list. I think that speaks volumes of Cotto's resume over Hatton's, imo.

[WhoreUs]

dude you ridiculous seriously he beat all those guys last i check winning is winning

i scored the clottey and mosley fights for cotto.

if torres had not been a last minute replacement and was better conditioned , he would have finished off cotto.

[WhoreUs]

the hatton hate on this site will never stop its sickkk

that's what i'm saying.

everyone knows hatton is superior to cotto yet people want to lie to themself.

[revs1227]

people know hatton after the floyd fite not the 5 yrs he owned his division ,,cotto never owned his division..he lost 2 marg haton ost 2 floyd

[Animalistic 5.0]

well it clearly is debatable isnt it

No is not. Just check the level of opposition and how both preformed.

[Grimmer]

and he got pac/floyd in his resume regardless...


hatton lost to the best p4p and are atgs

cotto lost to maragarito


see the difference




ohh i c




cotto ever face p4p kings? i dont think so

Subscribed. I'll come back to the point on Nov 15th.

[nujabes77]

did cotto tko/ko mosley?

where was mosley at that stage of his career?



cotto's resume has been well scripted.

shane at a time when everyone thought shane was shot and moving back down to 147.

judah after going winless in his last 3 fights.

the only times cotto really stepped up was with marg and cotto recently.

you can make a similar case for tszyu

I agree that Tzsyu is greater than Mosley but Cotto have a few more "Mosleys" (Judah and Quintana) while Hatton had only Tzsyu.

castillo/collazo > judah/quintana

hatton lasted longer against pacquiao than cotto will this november.

dont jinx it pare

[swizz]

better head movement.

better boxing skills.

better bodypunching.

more power.

faster handspeed.

better footwork.

better chin.

better jab.

better defense.

now you my friend has had too much too drink tonite

[WhoreUs]

Cotto no doubt.................hatton isnt really that bad.......Cotto on the other hand is borderline okay..........

fixed it .