Most Overrated Fighter and The Most Underrated Fighter

[Pretty Boy Greg]

Overrated- Kelly Pavlik

Underrated- Tim Bradley

[ragingvic]

Overrated- Paul Williams
Underrated- Joan Guzman

[Pretty Boy Greg]

Overrated- Paul Williams
Underrated- Joan Guzman

u really think Paul is overrated? i think he is a lil on NSB but he did beat winky in every round and he beat margacheato... plus he stopped phillips for the first time in his career...

[zalez787]

underrated , clottey
overrated, gamboa

[Mr. Fantastic]

Overrated - Juan Manuel Lopez

Underrated - Tim Bradley

[Bhopreign]

Depends, styles come into play alot. Against the right styles Pavlik will shine against good fighters.

[Bhopreign]

underrated , clottey
overrated, gamboa

I think Clottey is slightly underrated, but he fights to the level of competition mostly, which is his own fought.

[Check]

I don't like Pavlik but I would say calling him overrated is redic. Calling him the most overrated fighter in the world is something out of this world. The guy has only lost one time and that is to arguably a top 5 guy of the past 20 years. Him getting an injury has nothing to do with whats hes accomplished in the ring. Bradley is very underrated but that also has to do with how crappy his division is.

[street bully]

Overrated - Juan Manuel Lopez

Underrated - Tim Bradley

I agree. Do people still rate Lopez?

[Heru]

Most overrated = Roy Jones Jr. - The fact that people are excited and think he'll be competitive against B-Hop is ludicrous.

Most underrated = Joan Guzman - Not on NSB, but in the media. Quintana and Juand Diaz are underrated too.