What level are these fighters?

[Al Haymon]

De La Hoya-A

Pacquiao-A, agreed

Roy Jones-A, agreed

Hatton-B . A minus or B plus

Hopkins-A, agreed

Mayweather-A, agreed

Berto-B , TBD. just hitting his prime

Malignaggi-C, B fighter.

I put my edits above.

If Malignaggi is a C level fighter, then what do you consider Jesse James Leija-type guys?

If Malignaggi is C-level, then what is Ngoudjo, Ndou, Cherry, etc?

[P.WILL]

I read some people calling this fighter an "A" or "C" level fighter all the time so just tell me what you think these guys rate

De La Hoya----B+

Pacquiao---B+

Roy Jones---A

Hatton---B

Hopkins---A-

Mayweather---A

Berto---B-

Malignaggi---B+

.......................

[Sam D. Menace]

as of right now? or during their hay day?

[WhoreUs]

I read some people calling this fighter an "A" or "C" level fighter all the time so just tell me what you think these guys rate

De La Hoya

Pacquiao

Roy Jones

Hatton

Hopkins

Mayweather

Berto

Malignaggi

all those guys are A level fighters except berto and malignaggi.

A = top fighters , elite fighters , p4p level fighters
B = contenders , paper champions
C = gatekeepers , journeymen

[AllEyesOpen]

De La Hoya - A-

Pacquiao - A

Roy Jones - A

Hatton - C+

Hopkins - A-

Mayweather - A

Berto - B+

Malignaggi - B

Mind you i'm rating them in their prime.

[WhoreUs]

at the moment


De La Hoya- FAIL

Pacquiao- A

Roy Jones- B

Hatton- C+

Hopkins- A

Mayweather- A

Berto- B+

Malignaggi- B-

ricky hater.

[Pretty Boy Greg]

De La Hoya-C

Pacquiao-A

Roy Jones-B

Hatton-B

Hopkins-A

Mayweather-A

Berto-A

Malignaggi B

thats how i would rate them

[BOX-A-LOT]

I read some people calling this fighter an "A" or "C" level fighter all the time so just tell me what you think these guys rate

De La Hoya

Pacquiao

Roy Jones

Hatton

Hopkins

Mayweather

Berto

Malignaggi

The bar is set according to SRR standards!

De La Hoya: B- Tremendous skill and ability, but lacked the toughness in big-fights and outright ducking of Winky Wright!!

Pacquiao: B+ What more can we ask for from the PACMAN, he has delivered more than we thought possible. Has shown solid improvements in different areas of the sweet science

Roy Jones: B One of the most talented fighters to ever grace the earth. But, in the face of adversity, he has shown to have the De La Joto syndrome.

Hatton: C+, good athlete, tough and really low boxing IQ.

Hopkins: B- I simply can't grade him higher than RJJ, although he's way tougher than RJJ. His second-stage of his boxing career has proven to be more succesful than his first, smart matchmaking, has made him look better than he actually is.

Mayweather: B- Another once in a lifetime talent, excellent skills, but, who has he fought?

Berto: C+ Terrific speed, struggled against a contender enroute to a W.

Malignaggi: C+ Speedy, tough and that's about it.


** D*mn, some of you are giving out "A's" like it's peanuts, I wish I had y'all as my professors. **

I don't even give my favorite fighter an A.

[-Mbandit-]

I put my edits above.

If Malignaggi is a C level fighter, then what do you consider Jesse James Leija-type guys?

If Malignaggi is C-level, then what is Ngoudjo, Ndou, Cherry, etc?

I guess you are right, he was a champ and he beat some solid opposition so I guess I can change it to a B- but that is as high as I can go!

[joelab75]

All in their prime

De La Hoya, A minus

Pacquiao, A+

Roy Jones, A+

Hatton, B

Hopkins, A

Mayweather, A

Berto, B minus

Malignaggi, C minus