lightweigh ATG tournament who win this???

[Dambala]

True but that wasn't a LW it was at a catchweight of 145 I think? I am not saying Whitaker won't still beat him at LW. I am saying maybe at LW it would of been i little different.

Chavez best weight was 140, Whitaker would've beat him with ease at 135.

[Kevin Jesus]

Prime Whitaker beats all of those at the same time in the same ring even Floyd.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

i'd lean towards duran

[jrosales13]

Chavez best weight was 140, Whitaker would've beat him with ease at 135.

Maybe so but don't look at there fight at 145 to come to that conclusion. Chavez was not really a WW. Whitaker was a real WW. Whitaker was the bigger man in that fight. IMO at 135 might still win but I think it would be more competitive

[KILLA RIGHT]

duran hands down

[nachorjj]

True list of ATG LW

Roberto Duran
Pernell Whitaker
Benny Leonard
Joe Gans
Ike Williams
Tony Canzoneri

Manos de piedra (Hands of stone) wins it all...

Benny Leonard
Joe Gans
Ike Williams
Tony Canzoneri
i dont see any of this fighters... and when they fight was differnts rules other tipe of boxing

[The Underboss]

Duran at LW was a beast.

[jrosales13]

Benny Leonard
Joe Gans
Ike Williams
Tony Canzoneri
i dont see any of this fighters... and when they fight was differnts rules other tipe of boxing

Really? What rules were different? And, what other type of boxing was it?

[Joe2608]

Let's be honest, the only people on that list who you can debate as possible winners are Duran and Pernell. The others don't even belong in the same conversation with those names.

[boxasmash]

Duran>Whitaker>Mosley>Mayweather>Chavez>De La Hoya in that order at 135.