Placing TBud in an All Time Greatness Neighborhood

[SouthpawRight]

I think somewhere between top 13 to 20 all time would be it. Now he likely takes on 160

1. Sugar Robinson
2. Harry
3. Henry
4. Sam
5. Ezzard
6. Willie
7. Muhammad
8. Roberto
9. Joe
10. Sugar Leonard
11. Floyd
12. Benny
13. Pernell
14. manny
15. Jimmy
16. Archie
17. Carlos
18. Marvin
19. Barney
20. Tony
21. Julio Cesar

[Century Tuna]

I think somewhere between top 13 to 20 all time would be it. Now he likely takes on 160

1. Sugar Robinson
2. Harry
3. Henry
4. Sam
5. Ezzard
6. Willie
7. Muhammad
8. Roberto
9. Joe
10. Sugar Leonard
11. Floyd
12. Benny
13. Pernell
14. manny
15. Jimmy
16. Archie
17. Carlos
18. Marvin
19. Barney
20. Tony
21. Julio Cesar

Slot him at 14 and kick that tiny, jungle-born Asian loser off the list.

[SouthpawRight]

Slot him at 14 and kick that tiny, jungle-born Asian loser off the list.

why so negatively fixated on manny

Maybe 13 if he finishes strong at 160 and retires undefeated

[The Big Dunn]

Only male in 4 belt era to have 3 unified weights. Went up 2 weight classes and clearly defeated the cash cow and top 7 p4p boxer by a wide margin.

That deserves respect.

[LuckyMarciano]

Crawford is my favorite fighter, but it's hard for him to arguably take the top spot, with that being said I could see Tbud winning against Floyd, Leonard and Duran. So I would place him top 8-7

[SouthpawRight]

Crawford is my favorite fighter, but it's hard for him to arguably take the top spot, with that being said I could see Tbud winning against Floyd, Leonard and Duran. So I would place him top 8-7

that number is high

Sugar Leonard and Floyd each ran through multiple all time opponents.

TBud has one so far

[Brother Mouzone]

He is already an ATG , discussion should be more about GOAT status which is more of a representation of your list.......

[SouthpawRight]

He is already an ATG , discussion should be more about GOAT status which is more of a representation of your list.......

by definition there can only be ONE goat

my top 5 all time list are the untouchables

modern boxing is structured in a way that won't ever allow any contemporary fighter to breach the top 5 all time

1 or 2 fights per year isn't cutting it

[Brother Mouzone]

by definition there can only be ONE goat

my top 5 all time list are the untouchables

modern boxing is structured in a way that won't ever allow any contemporary fighter to breach the top 5 all time

1 or 2 fights per year isn't cutting it

This is true , but screw that the top 10 guys on your list could be #1 (GOAT) on someone else's list .

[SouthpawRight]

This is true , but screw that the top 10 guys on your list could be #1 (GOAT) on someone else's list .

why like Muhammad so much