Who is greater all time: Pac or Duran

[ijudge]

then again manny was 40.5 years old when he beat Keith

and 46.5 years old when he drew with Mario

manny was 36 and had more left in the tank when Floyd 10-2’d him

Manny peaked in 2010.
Every year after that was a substantial decline from his peak.

sure he still has something left in the tank but the amount left is not the same as the full tank in 2010.
floyd never fought the full version.

Leonard at least beat Duran before he got slept by Hearns.
Floyd fought the one the Manny that got KO'd already.
sure theres still some crumbs of glory for beating duran after hearns.
duran still has tank left especially beating barkley.
but you're getting little to no credit for that.
thats not peak duran.
not peak manny.

also the scorecards were 116-112.
floyd almost drew with a guy with one arm

[SouthpawRight]

Manny peaked in 2010.
Every year after that was a substantial decline from his peak.

also the scorecards were 116-112.
floyd almost drew with a guy with one arm

Floyd's Prime ENDED in 2007

using YOUR logic and going by scorecards it was 117-111 116-112 114-114. two scorecards had Marcos FAR from a draw

You also CONVENIENTLY left out Judge Dave Moretti's score Floyd 118-110 manny taking only rounds 4 and 6

A further past it Floyd capped manny to taking only two clear rounds

manny waited for Floyd to look mortal against Marcos first

only then did manny agree to a fight Floyd

it BACKFIRED on manny anyways as a further past it Floyd 10-2'd him

[SouthpawRight]

Duran is King, no the Emperor of Boxing. The GOAT

Roberto is contender for most skilled ever

manny is not

[NotIron]

Manny peaked in 2010.
Every year after that was a substantial decline from his peak.

sure he still has something left in the tank but the amount left is not the same as the full tank in 2010.
floyd never fought the full version.

Leonard at least beat Duran before he got slept by Hearns.
Floyd fought the one the Manny that got KO'd already.
sure theres still some crumbs of glory for beating duran after hearns.
duran still has tank left especially beating barkley.
but you're getting little to no credit for that.
thats not peak duran.
not peak manny.

also the scorecards were 116-112.
floyd almost drew with a guy with one arm

116-112 is 8 rounds to 4.

That's not "almost a draw".

Also one card was 118-110 which is 10 rounds to 2.

[TheProudLunatic]

chronological age is a less reliable measurement of aging in boxing compared to biological age.

Wilfred Benitez was already a shot fighter at age 25 after facing five hall of famers.

Floyd is older in a chronological sense but Pacquiao has more wear and tear in his body.

Pac also never tested positive in any of his fights including his latest one.

Pac fought some if the least threatening guys. Practically his entire WW segment except for Sometime.

May had chronically bad hands.
Pac was too scared to do random blood tests.
Would YOU have avoided the needle ?
Nor a single Pac fan wants to answer that

[TheProudLunatic]

"Would YOU have avoided the needle ?
Not a single Pac fan wants to answer that"

And the streak continues

[TheProudLunatic]

Pacquaio has never once said he was afraid of needles.

The act of his blood leaving his body 21 days prior to a fight is the same thing.

Let me ask you....

Would YOU have avoided random blood tests ?!?!?
Not a single Pac fan wants to answer this incredible simple question

[NotIron]

I have only one thing against Pac, his refusal to get tested and the lame excuse "I'm afraid of needles", before that I always cheered for him, then I was positive he was using PED'S.

Pacquaio has never once said he was afraid of needles.

[NotIron]

The act of his blood leaving his body 21 days prior to a fight is the same thing.

Let me ask you....

Would YOU have avoided random blood tests ?!?!?
Not a single Pac fan wants to answer this incredible simple question

It's actually not the same thing.

Pacquaio never said he was afraid of needles ever. So it's objectively false to say that he did.

[TheProudLunatic]

It's actually not the same thing.

Pacquaio never said he was afraid of needles ever. So it's objectively false to say that he did.

You dodged the last part like Pac dodged the random test !!!!!