New P4P Rankings

[Super_Lightweight]

hmm

Give me your ranking foolio. I could care less what you think about mine. I wanna see yours!

Fine. I don't like to make p4p's though...they are just difficult to do and most of time are so subjective. Stricly looking at it by who is better on a pound-4-pound scale.

1) Floyd Mayweather
2) Kostya Tszyu
3) Bernard Hopkins
4) Erik Morales
5) Winky Wright (could easily switch with Morales)
6) Pac
7) Barrera
8) Trinidad
9) Jose Luis Castillo
10) Diego Corrales

[glitxbs]

I'm getting confused on the rankings of Barrera, Morales, and Pac. How do you base your rankings for the three of them? If you look at their recent records and performance against P4P contenders, you're gonna have all three pretty even:
EM - 1-1 (Pac win - Barrera loss)
MAB - 1-1 (EM win - Pac loss)
PAC - 1-1 (MAB win - EM loss)
Other factors:
- MAB win over HAMED
- MAB beat EM twice already
- PAC beat MAB in a TKO blowout fashion
- PAC draw with Marquez (both EM & MAB hasn't fought JMM yet)
- Except for MAB/PAC, other fights were won by CLOSE DEC

[Agave]

So What's your guy's new P4P rankings after the fight tonite?

Its damn hard b/c you got Tszyu/B-Hop/Mayweather(?)/Morales/Pac-Man/G.Johnson

IMO:
1. B-Hop
2. Erik Morales
3. Tszyu
4. Glen Johnson
5. PBF
6. Pacquiao

If I'm leaving out anyone its probably b/c they havn't had any exciting PPV/HBO/ST fights. I only give B-Hop #1 b/c that guy is a mutant. Tszyu & Morales could go both ways but I'm obviously biased lolz. Shyt, cant really think of anyone else other than Glen Johnson getting up in there, but its all about the little guys now!

You left Barrera out!!! Wasn't his last fight exciting..?

[mic573]

1. Hopkins
2. Mayweather
3. Tszyu
4. Morales
5. Wright (until Tito beats him)

[The Fix]

1. pbf- skills are unmatched
2. b-hop- ageless
3. zoo- power,accuracy
4. wright- slick southpaw
5. mab- great defense
6. morales- can trade wit anyone
7. pacman- speed and power
8. zab- one of the most talented in the world
9. castillo- pushed pbf to limit, fought great competition
10. spinks - why no more love for spinks? imo he is still top 10

[Floydmayweather]

1.Tszyu- underated power and accuarte punching
2.Floyd-Close needs 1 or 2 big wins to be #1
3.B-hop- 20 need i say more
4.Barrera- Great warrior beat Morales 2x
5.Morales- Huge win over Pacman has him climbing back to the top
6.Pacman- Never say die attitude and speed keeps him in any fight
7.Judah- Undistuped champ
8.Tito- I hate him but he connects and its all over
9.Castillo- Fights the best and beats the best
10.Wright- Consistent fighter never backs down from a challenge

[TyrantT316]

1.Tszyu- underated power and accuarte punching
2.Floyd-Close needs 1 or 2 big wins to be #1
3.B-hop- 20 need i say more
4.Barrera- Great warrior beat Morales 2x
5.Morales- Huge win over Pacman has him climbing back to the top
6.Pacman- Never say die attitude and speed keeps him in any fight
7.Judah- Undistuped champ
8.Tito- I hate him but he connects and its all over
9.Castillo- Fights the best and beats the best
10.Wright- Consistent fighter never backs down from a challenge

lol...I don't think Kostya's power is underrated...we all pretty much know the cat can hit

[jayschre]

This is a pound 4 pound scale dude...you seriously think if Glen or Zoo was the same size as Mayweather they would be able to beat him? Or Morales? Doubt it.

Just curious but when you ask "if Glen or zoo were the same size as Mayweather", do you not realize that Tszyu and Mayweather are in fact in the same division now? And I for one happen to think that Kostya Tszyu would hammer Pretty boy Floyd into the ground.

[TheGreat1]

Here it is -

1A. Floyd (the fastest, best D, undefeated)
1B. Hopkins (the smartest, best counter-puncher, 20 defenses & going)
3. Tszyu (the best when he wants 2 be)
4. Barrera (a living legend)
5. Morales (see #4)
6. Winky (consistency counts)
7. Tito (watch out Winky)
8. Glencoffe (King of the Upset)
9. Pacquaio (W,L or D, a thrilling prizefighter)
10. Zab (let's give the kid some credit already!)

Great list, i would only make 1 change, Glen johnson should be replaced with Tarver, who completly outboxed him in there fight.

[BBFM]

bernard hopkins needs to be deleted i always thought you had to fight in a different weight to be pound for pound and why isent de la hoya in that list.