Name your 10 best super middleweights

[lparm]

Got some good feedback for the middleweights thread so now let's try a much more difficult division to judge.

1.Calzaghe
2. Park
3. RJJ
4. Toney
5. Eubank
6. Benn
7. Collins
8. Ottke
9. Liles
10. Beyer

Try not to name fighters that were one and done at the weight, and actually defended a title.

[lparm]

In light of the super 6 starting soon

ze bump

[SCtrojansbaby]

Got some good feedback for the middleweights thread so now let's try a much more difficult division to judge.

1.Calzaghe
2. Park
3. RJJ
4. Toney
5. Eubank
6. Benn
7. Collins
8. Ottke
9. Liles
10. Beyer

Try not to name fighters that were one and done at the weight, and actually defended a title.

LMAO

Top 3 no order are Toney RJJ and Ottke

[D-MiZe]

LMAO

Top 3 no order are Toney RJJ and Ottke

You fucking silly ****.

[coghaugen]

Toney was fantastic against Barkley, Littles and Charles Williams.

Eubank had fantastic fights with Watson, Benn, Rocchigiani and Wharton.

It's between those two.

I know Jones was unreal against (blown-up lightweight) Pazienza, did what he did against (drained from heavyweight weight) Toney. And I know Calzaghe had all those years (largely down to fighting once or twice a year) and this supposedly great Lacy thing. And I know the whole Benn-McClellan business with Nigel Benn.

But I feel it's between Toney and Eubank.


1) Toney/Eubank
3) Jones
4) Benn
5) Calzaghe

[Benncollinsaad]

Got some good feedback for the middleweights thread so now let's try a much more difficult division to judge.

1.Calzaghe
2. Park
3. RJJ
4. Toney
5. Eubank
6. Benn
7. Collins
8. Ottke
9. Liles
10. Beyer

Try not to name fighters that were one and done at the weight, and actually defended a title.

How can you put Ottke ahead of Liles?! And Beyer is a ***ing douchebag who always got saved by dq's! Got destroyed by Kessler like a 10 yearold.

And who da heck is Park?!?

[coghaugen]

Ottke was a joke. Admittedly haven't seen Park. Liles wasn't up to much to be honest.

Leonard and Hearns fought there as well. And Nunn.

[Benncollinsaad]

Ottke was a joke. Admittedly haven't seen Park. Liles wasn't up to much to be honest.

Leonard and Hearns fought there as well. And Nunn.

Liles beat Nunn. And he was the WBA champ for four years.