Should Mayweather record read 39-1-25?

[Kevin Jesus]

why do people keep posting this recycled ****??the fight was 8 years ago,floyd won a close fight and gave him an immediate rematch to erase all doubt...and you think fighters should watch a 8 year old tape on how to beat floyd???floyd was injured in that fight,and then corrected any errors he made in the second fight

If you talk about Cotto-Mosley which was 2 years ago, posters will react as if it was really a long time ago and they say "Let this go man it's in the past".

But when it's something about Castillo-Mayweather or the "knockdown" that Judah gave Mayweather(these fights are older than Cotto-Mosley), posters happily contribute to threads on those subjects.

[Bushidō]

shiet I could sit here and say Cotto should be undefeated but I'm not going to cause he still has a loss on his record. If the higher power took the loss away then I would say okay he is undefeated but he is not

[Webber676]

He won the remach but lost the first fight fairly.

[Doctor_Tenma]

I'll keep saying this, JLC was given alot of credit for landing shots he wasn't even landing. That said, I still believe it could have gone either way.

[Bushidō]

A lot of Castillo's punches were landing on Mayweather shoulders and arms.

[R.Winky Wright]

I had Castillo ahead on the cards too, but the judges ruled in Floyd's favor, that's that.

Why does this **** pop up here constantly?

desperation anything to make may look shaky. fact remains he is BEST P4P

PAC lost to JMM in their first fight and it was close on their second. but judges gave both to pac... so what.

[larry x]

castillo lost to floyd twice-fact

so your opinion means jack****

[DLT]

I just watched Mayweather vs Castillo I fight for the first time and holly sh__t, now me too agree with thousands of people that have been saying that Castillo was robbed in that fight and even in Lederman's score card he won the fight.

I know Mayweather knows this fact deep inside him and any fighter that want a good reference as how to beat him should watch this fight closely. HELLO Manny, Cotto, Mosley!

seriously though, I dont think Floyd reached his prime until the N'Dou fight so they can watch the JLC match all they want but he's definatly grown since then in all areas. He's not that same guy anymore

[Doctor_Tenma]

seriously though, I dont think Floyd reached his prime until the N'Dou fight so they can watch the JLC match all they want but he's definatly grown since then in all areas. He's not that same guy anymore

I'd say, Mayweather stopped improving at Jr WW. Although, the "JAB" is back.

[The Gambler1981]

I will say what I always say about this fight, JLC gave away the first half of the fight the first six rounds all favored Mayweather, if a fighter loses the first six rounds it is hard to get a decision. I believe all the judges gave 5 out of the first six rounds for Mayweather, JLC had to sweep the last rounds to win and the last 6 rounds were very close so there is no way JLC won them all.

It was a close good fight but scoring round by round I believe the right man won.