Apart from the 1993 version Of Roy Jones Jr...

[Chr0nic]

Sorry dude, that post wasn't necessarily directed at you. I wanted to set the record straight in regards to who was at what weight back then.

no problem

[civicvx]

I don't know but Calzaghe sure beat the hell out of those two.

[Roger Mellie]

I don't know but Calzaghe sure beat the hell out of those two.

Green k given,just for the responses you are likely to get!

[WhoreUs]

One sunny day people will acknowledge Calzaghe and Hopkins as being great fighters without all this gay,top trump, atg,hofer bull****....maybe.

roy jones >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> calzaghe + hopkins

[Roger Mellie]

roy jones >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> calzaghe + hopkins

Danny Williams>>>>>>>>>>> 'em all!

[WhoreUs]

Danny Williams>>>>>>>>>>> 'em all!

yeah but has he ever won the prziefighter tournament like audley harrison?

[Kris Silver]

A poll might have been good because all that's stirred up is a bit of defensiveness with additional questions...

Calzaghe goes through Hopkins resume apart from Jones, undefeated.

This has come up before.

In the higher weights you have Tarver, Winky, Pavlik, Taylor for example.

Calzaghe beats all of them by clear UD's and polls on them has shown as much. The toughest one would probably be the best skilled which is probably Taylor. Taylor would still be out worked, would not be quite quick enough, could not adapt to the onslaught of punches and pressure even if not as powerful as previously experienced. He'd get out worked and lose the latter 2/3rd's of the fight as usual with Calzaghe, particularly because he gasses.

So it's difficult to see what case can be made for the contrary on any of those guys beating Cal with consensus being with Calzaghe on all said names.

[IMDAZED]

A poll might have been good because all that's stirred up is a bit of defensiveness with additional questions?

Calzaghe goes through Hopkins resume apart from Jones, undefeated.

This has come up before.

In the higher weights you have Tarver, Winky, Pavlik, Taylor for example.

Calzaghe beats all of them by clear UD's and polls on them has shown as much.

So it's difficult to see what case can be made for the contrary with much weight, to be honest...

I think the reason why people find this debate pointless is that the same works for Hopkins..except he probably beats everyone on Calzaghe's resume.

[VipersThunder]

Name me one fighter on Hopkins resume that Calzaghe couldn't beat?

What diffrence does it make? Can Slappy make 160 to fight any of them? And Tarver, Pavlik Johnson Wright Taylor all would have had a shot against ***gy boy.

[IMDAZED]

What diffrence does it make? Can Slappy make 160 to fight any of them? And Tarver, Pavlik Johnson Wright Taylor all would have had a shot against ***gy boy.

Pavlik would've got his lunch money taken, Taylor would have collapsed in round 9, Johnson was too green, Wright too small, but Tarver...hmm...Tarver...