If floyd had fought Marquez at his best weight would he won as dominately?

[baracuda]

A young Juan M. Marquez in his natural weight where he still has speed and floyd is skinny had a chane of winning. Floyds strength was a key factor. Marquez would've probally been the stronger fighter and I think he is better than Jose Luis Castillo. So that says it all.

jmm>>>>jlc prime for prime!....

[shadeyfizzle]

Pacman fought Marquez at weight classes Marquez looked much better at. Basically if Marquez and Floyd could have fought at comfortable weight classes where weight didn't make a difference. Basically that could never happen since the more weight Marquez went up the worse he seemed to have gotten.

Marquez may have won some rounds and actually rock Mayweather a couple of times but Mayweather would still have won in dominant fashion because Marquez is a counterpuncher 1st and foremost and against Floyd he was forced to be offensive which he is not comfortable with so floyd wins in dominant fashion no matter what weightclass it is.

Difference being Marquez would actually have a puncher's chance as opposed to none at all though.

[sL0]

pbf used to fight at 130 early in his career, so I guess I'm saying that version of floyd vs Marquez at 130. Basically if they had fought back then.

If you've have happened to watch Mayweather at 130 then you can come to this conclusion, wow. He displayed incredible speed, the same defense he's know for plus an added bonus, he threw more combination's and displayed greater power. Do I think it would've been the same dominant performance, YES I do. The only disadvantage Floyd would have would be his brittle hands.

[Bushidō]

why are we still talking about Marquez and Mayweather

[Sin City]

I think Floyd would've won but the fight would've been a lot closer.

[Doctor_Tenma]

Mayweather was even better at 130, MUCH faster...I'd be less competitive. This is no different from when people said, "What if Mayweather had faught Hatton at 140?", Mayweather would have destroyed Hatton even worse. Ofcourse, Marquez would have been alot better but so would Mayweather. My thing was, I didn't think Marquez would be ****** enough to enter the ring at 148 and I didn't expect Mayweather to look that good after a 2 year layoff.

[El Angel]

He does better, I'm just not sure if he can win or not still. Mayweather was a beast at 130 and Marquez's prime years were at 126.