Too bad MOSLEY and TRINIDAD never fough!!!!!

[jrosales13]

At what weight?

[Young Mike]

At what weight?

It doesn't matter from 140 to 154 Trinidad wins.

[jrosales13]

It doesn't matter from 140 to 154 Trinidad wins.

Trinidad for awhile had problems making 147. If they fougth at 140 I like Shane to beat a very weak TIto. And, Tito is my favorite fighter. At 154 I think Trinidad wins. I always thought that was Tito best weight. And, I never liked how Shane looked at 154. IMO Shane neve carried the 154 weight well. At 160 I think Tito wins. Now at 147, I don't know that is a hard one for me to pick cuz I am such a Tito fan.

[biglou88]

I dont know man, Trinidad always had problems against 'BOXERS'...

Shanes' a boxer.

Actually Shane is more of a brawler with speed.

[biglou88]

trinidad was tailor made for mosley imo. Name me one come forward bralwer mosley ever had trouble with let alone lost to?

he lost to cotto, most of the fight was upclose the last 3 rounds cotto outboxed him.

[Bushidō]

Any reason why?????

He lost to Winky. He took a "tune-up" and it was Winky

[Bushidō]

I don't know. Trinidad at Mosley at 160 would have meant that Trinidad had all the advantages. Mosley isn't your typical boxer that can beat you with a jab. You need a pretty decent jab to beat Trinidad. If I had to put money on it I think Trinidad would have won a decision especially since the fight would have took place at 160

[tito yuca]

Trinidad for awhile had problems making 147. If they fougth at 140 I like Shane to beat a very weak TIto. And, Tito is my favorite fighter. At 154 I think Trinidad wins. I always thought that was Tito best weight. And, I never liked how Shane looked at 154. IMO Shane neve carried the 154 weight well. At 160 I think Tito wins. Now at 147, I don't know that is a hard one for me to pick cuz I am such a Tito fan.

What kind of analysis is this? Neither of them fought at 140 (well, Tito did when he was starting out, but that doesn't really mean anything here), and Shane didn't fight at 160, so you can throw that out of the window. Also, how can you say it's hard to pick at 147 but at 154 Tito wins? Tito fought exactly the same way at 154 and 147, he only moved up because he couldn't make the weight. It wasn't until after the B-Hop fight (at 160) that Tito started to depent too much on trying to land one big shot.

As far as who would win, I lean towards Shane by a bit. Shane was very fast, and although he isn't really a slick-boxer type, he'd have no problems with Tito's straight-ahead style. Both of them only lost to guys who gave them lateral movement, so it would be a very interesting fight to watch. The key difference in this matchup is Shane's speed. Oscar couldn't handle it in their first fight, and Oscar has better boxing skills than Tito, as well as a better chin. Tito's power is his best weapon in this fight, but I think he'd find it hard to land on Shane.

[Animalistic 5.0]

Tito at 154 or 160 would have been too much for Mosley to handle. I don't know if Tito KO's Mosley at those weights because Mosley chin is great, but Mosley would take a serious beating.

147 would be a 50/50 fight with both Trinidad and Mosley in their primes maybe with a slight edge to Trinidad because of his size, power and the fact Mosley is a fighter and not a boxer like many make him out to be so Mosley would fight.

At 147 it would be a classic!

[flyest1]

Tito at 154 or 160 would have been too much for Mosley to handle. I don't know if Tito KO's Mosley at those weights becauseMosley chin is great but Mosley would take a serious beating.

147 would be a 50/50 fight with both Trinidad and Mosley in their primes maybe with a slight edge to Trinidad because of his size, power and the fact Mosley is a fighter and not a boxer like many make him out to be so Mosley would fight.

At 147 it would be a classic!

Great post