Would you all agree that floyd mayweather jr. is the MOST GIFTED(wins) FIGHTER OF ALL TIME?

[djtmal]

Now if you want to compare anybody from Floyds era go ahead, I chose Manny because of how highly regarded he is, for some reason to compare Floyd and Manny head to head is frightening to you.

Reading is still fundamental i see....


Manny isnt a top tier all time great he's sitting around top 30 same as Floyd despite his undefeated cherrypicked record.

[djtmal]

[QUOTE=Roadblock;n31817109]

Floyd beat Canelo and Manny both ATG fighters and Floyd was not near his prime when he beat them, both went on to win big fights and both would have beaten a truck load of elite fighters the night Floyd beat them.

Ha Canelo Alvarez is NOT, i repeat, NOT an all time great fighter. He's lucky if he cracks top 75 gtfoh

Manny Pacquaio another shopwornfighter you Floyd boys desperately cling onto because he does not have a win against an all time great fighter in their prime.

Stick to Hatton and Corrales please nobody will blink an eye

[djtmal]

[QUOTE=Roadblock;n31817109]

The irony is hilarious, you hate Floyd and love Manny, they fought during the same era with many of the same opponents, fought each other and they are two of the most linked fighters in history, yet you cant bare to compare them head to head, run away you hating mop.

Whats getting real hilarious is your inability to comprehend:

Reading is still fundamental i see....


Manny isnt a top tier all time great he's sitting around top 30 same as Floyd despite his undefeated cherrypicked record.

[Roadblock]

[QUOTE=djtmal;n31817127]

Whats getting real hilarious is your inability to comprehend:

Reading is still fundamental i see....


Manny isnt a top tier all time great he's sitting around top 30 same as Floyd despite his undefeated cherrypicked record.

Reading is fundamental you say as you do chop suey on a post, lol your brain never ceases to amaze.

ATG rating is nothing more than fantasy opinion, its totally meaningless in any conversation while assessing resumes of fighters from the same era, I don't care where people rate anybody all I know is where ever the rating is Floyd is higher than Manny, another realism that gives you nightmares.

You are too much like a girl that fears reality to debate, you like fantasy too much.

[BodyBagz]

A real boxing fan will be hard pressed to find so many cherries on one resume as this next fighter

This guys 1st 40 fights

Diaz
Larios
Solis
Hatton was a bum but not quite a cherry
Shot to shlt DLH* (''No one beat DLH* like Pac did ''...Yeah, no one else had the chance to fight the worst version of DLH* )
Clottey
Cotto* (obviously not a cherry but ''forced'' into being his worst version. Could have said no but money talks)
Shot Margarito* (this fugging bum . 1 handed Clottey was clowning the bum. Margie is a Pac Boi's favorite )
Shot Mosley
Shot Algieri*
Shot Rios, AKA, Baby Margarito
Desert Breeze 3x (obviously not a cherry, but, did we need 3 of these ?)
Shot Broner (Maidana's son)
Shot Lucas
Some guy names Vargas, couldn't hurt a persons feelings
A part time school teacher, full time slob HORN (CPGW)
Basic AF Ugas...we may never see him on live tv again

Name the legend who fought these certified cherries (and only mostly won)

[djtmal]

[QUOTE=Roadblock;n31817197]

ATG rating is nothing more than fantasy opinion,.

That's what you trying to push because you know your man crush Floyd, in the annals of history, despite his undefeated record, isn't seen by boxing analysts, historians, etc., as the best of all times in any era, or even cracks top 5, top 10, top 15, top 20 that's still rare air accompanied by guys like srr, srl, Ali Duran, etc.

Nobody really cares what you think it should be.

You want to make excuses for him and keep him in a weak era why, because it makes him look better than what he really is.

The best are judged by who they beat and when they beat them and is compared to the greats of past eras. We not giving Floyd consolation prizes over here.

[djtmal]

A real boxing fan will be hard pressed to find so many cherries on one resume as this next fighter


Hatton was a bum but not quite a cherry

Hatton, that same bum, is one of the absolute best guys on Floyds resume.

[djtmal]

[QUOTE=Roadblock;n31817197]

ATG rating is nothing more than fantasy opinion, its totally meaningless in any conversation while assessing resumes of fighters from the same era, I don't care where people rate anybody all I know is where ever the rating is Floyd is higher than Manny, another realism that gives you nightmares.

Gtfoh.

Countless all time great lists have both those guys sitting between 20 and 30. Along guys like Roy Jones, Hopkins, etc. What does that mean that means they pretty much are seem the same. Some list have Floyd a rank or two higher some have Manny up over him.

Maybe you should stick to telling your Jeff Fenech stories

[djtmal]

[QUOTE=Roadblock;n31817197]

I don't care where people rate anybody all I know is where ever the rating is Floyd is

Spoken like a true delusional Floyd boy.

[djtmal]

A real boxing fan will be hard pressed to find so many cherries
Shot to shlt DLH* (''No one beat DLH* like Pac did ''...Yeah, no one else had the chance to fight the worst version of DLH* )

Manny fought the same version of Oscar Floyd did, one year later after Floyd btw.

Oscar was the favorite against Manny and called all the shots, when Oscar got the brakes beat off him by Manny worse than what Floyd could ever do, Oscar was shot, weight drained, etc. now he is the "worst version" ok