ESPN Women's P4P list is very questionable.

[Queen_Leia]

So ESPN released it's women's pound for pound list and I have to say, I have a problem with this order & with some of the names on this list outright but I want to here opinions on it.


1. Claressa Shields
2. Katie Taylor
3. Amanda Serrano
4. Alycia Baumgarder
5. Jessica McCaskill
6. Mikaela Mayer
7. Chantelle Cameron
8. Seneisa Estrada
9. Franchon Crews-Dezurn
10. Natasha Jonas


Also on a side note, does Skye Nicholson deserve to be on this list?

[pretty boy_]

Number 1 is correct. Super Bad Seniesa should be number 3 IMO. Other than that I’d say it’s aight.

[Queen_Leia]

Number 1 is correct. Super Bad Seniesa should be number 3 IMO. Other than that I’d say it’s aight.

Seniesa is a problem...she still hold the record for fastest KO in Boxing history?

[The D3vil]

Mine would go.

1. Shields
2. Serrano
3. Taylor
4. Baumgardner
5. Cameron
6. Estrade
7. Jonas
8. Franchon
9. Mayer
10. McCaskill

Shields & Serrano are multiweight phenomenons.

I never understand why Taylor gets so much credit for basically parking at 135 and barely (if that) beating Persoon in the first fight.

Serrano fought at 115 & 140 the same year and almost beat Taylor even thought she is naturally 2 weight classes smaller than Katie.

Shields is undisputed in 3 different division.

[dannnnn]

Even if there were only ten female boxers in total (which there may as well be), Jessica McCaskill wouldn't belong on a top ten list. She's horrendous.

As for Mayer, I thought she should have got the nod over Baumgardner so she deserves her place for me. Skye Nicholson is probably good enough to be there, as is Savannah Marshall unless she's retired. I dunno, it's kind of hard to say who's very good in women's boxing because none of them are, really. Deciding who's better than who is a bit of a 'tallest midget' scenario.

[deathofaclown]

People actually take it seriously?

the only thread needed on women’s boxing happened last week, regarding who is the best looking.

The talent pool in women’s boxing is horrendous. You have a handful of women boxers who have some ok technique through enough practice. The other 99.9% are lesbians who took up boxercise classes.

That’s why you get completely useless women boxers winning world titles within 3 fights

Im convinced if you were a woman who took boxing seriously for 6 months, you could become a pro and pick up a world title in some divisions.

[deathofaclown]

Mine would go.

1. Shields
2. Serrano
3. Taylor
4. Baumgardner
5. Cameron
6. Estrade
7. Jonas
8. Franchon
9. Mayer
10. McCaskill

Shields & Serrano are multiweight phenomenons.

I never understand why Taylor gets so much credit for basically parking at 135 and barely (if that) beating Persoon in the first fight.

Serrano fought at 115 & 140 the same year and almost beat Taylor even thought she is naturally 2 weight classes smaller than Katie.

Shields is undisputed in 3 different division.

Chantelle Cameron might be the best out of all of them, she just hasn’t got the titles in multiple divisions.

Taylor won’t fight her.

[removed]

People actually take it seriously?

the only thread needed on women’s boxing happened last week, regarding who is the best looking.

The talent pool in women’s boxing is horrendous. You have a handful of women boxers who have some ok technique through enough practice. The other 99.9% are lesbians who took up boxercise classes.

That’s why you get completely useless women boxers winning world titles within 3 fights

Im convinced if you were a woman who took boxing seriously for 6 months, you could become a pro and pick up a world title in some divisions.

The only competent female boxer is Shields, the rest of them are useless.

[The D3vil]

Chantelle Cameron might be the best out of all of them, she just hasn’t got the titles in multiple divisions.

Taylor won’t fight her.

Yeah, Cameron's live against anybody from 135-147

[Shadoww702]

Mine would go.

1. Shields
2. Serrano
3. Taylor
4. Baumgardner
5. Cameron
6. Estrade
7. Jonas
8. Franchon
9. Mayer
10. McCaskill

Shields & Serrano are multiweight phenomenons.

I never understand why Taylor gets so much credit for basically parking at 135 and barely (if that) beating Persoon in the first fight.

Serrano fought at 115 & 140 the same year and almost beat Taylor even thought she is naturally 2 weight classes smaller than Katie.

Shields is undisputed in 3 different division.

Last I saw Taylor beat Serrano?